Ghost in the Shell has achieved classic status in the anime realm, but its 2017 live-action adaptation has sparked mixed reactions, often falling short of acclaim despite notable strengths. Originating as a manga in 1989, it played a pivotal role in shaping the cyberpunk genre, and the subsequent 1995 anime film solidified its status. The sequel, titled Ghost in the Shell 2: Innocence, released in 2004, received lukewarm reviews, holding a 65% rating on Rotten Tomatoes. Yet, among all adaptations, the American live-action version remains one of the most debated.
The 2017 film, directed by Rupert Sanders, contains carefully crafted elements, from Ishikawa’s backstory to the distinctive look of the Major, portrayed by Scarlett Johansson. Despite these details, the film faced backlash from both manga readers and anime enthusiasts for various justified grievances. Johansson’s compelling performance as the cybernetic counter-terrorism agent was overshadowed by accusations of whitewashing, which detracted from the film’s many achievements.
Why Ghost In The Shell (2017) Deserves Another Look
Unique Aspects of Rupert Sanders’ Ghost In The Shell
Despite its shortcomings, Rupert Sanders’ adaptation of Ghost in the Shell boasts several commendable features. To truly grasp the film’s essence, viewers should revisit Masamune Shirow’s acclaimed manga and the original anime. This combination allows audiences to appreciate the narrative intentions behind these iconic works. Notably, the 2017 adaptation shines in its captivating sci-fi aesthetic, boasting impressive visuals and effects, which, while divisive, are generally recognized for their quality.
With its sharp cinematography and cool color palette, the film adeptly captures the cyberpunk essence intrinsic to its source material. Johansson’s depiction of the Major, while diverging from the original narrative, aesthetically aligns with the manga’s spirit. It’s crucial to note that the film wasn’t created strictly as an authentic adaptation, allowing for a fresh interpretation of familiar elements. The live-action villain introduces a unique narrative angle, drawing inspiration from the anime while presenting a distinct story that incorporates Hollywood-style action sequences.
Viewing Ghost In The Shell’s Live-Action Film as a Standalone Experience
The Live-Action Ghost In The Shell: A Story of Its Own
As a reimagining of one of the most revered anime films, the live-action Ghost in the Shell inevitably faced scrutiny when compared to its predecessor. While some comparisons are essential for a thorough evaluation—ensuring high standards in storytelling and representation—viewers are likely to derive more enjoyment from the film when considered on its own terms. Understanding its context enriches the experience, yet appreciating it independently reveals a uniquely engaging narrative.
Instead of striving for exact fidelity to Shirow’s original story, the film carves out its own path, bringing a novel perspective that expands the franchise’s lore. While its soundtrack and action sequences may not rank among the year’s finest in sci-fi, they deliver sufficient entertainment value and should be examined alongside the Japanese Ghost in the Shell content for a holistic understanding.