The reality series Below Deck Sailing Yacht has recently faced significant challenges, largely attributed to the controversial actions of cast member Gary King. As we approach the premiere of season 6, it’s becoming increasingly clear that a comprehensive recast is necessary, save for Captain Glenn Shephard, who remains a steadfast presence amidst the chaos. Gary’s detrimental influence has spread among the crew, primarily through his tumultuous relationship with Chief Stew Daisy Kelliher.
Gary demonstrated a lack of responsibility when he openly disregarded Captain Glenn’s strict two-drink policy during an outing with guests. Instead of acknowledging his mistake, he opted for denial, which speaks to his character flaws. His reckless behavior also resulted in an incident involving Chief Engineer Davide Morosi, where he left blood stains on a white couch, and he attempted to sabotage Daisy’s budding relationship with Deckhand Keith Allen. The time has come for Bravo to reconsider the entire lineup, not just Gary. Here’s why a fresh approach is essential.
Drama Central: Gary’s Reign of Chaos
Is it Still Entertainment?
Gary’s pattern of disruptive behavior isn’t new; it has marred previous seasons as well. During seasons 2 and 3, he instigated drama right from the get-go by getting involved with Deckhand Sydney Zaruba, a situation that quickly unraveled when her feelings deepened against Gary’s intentions. This set the stage for a toxic love triangle as he pursued Stew Alli Dore, straining onboard relationships.
However, the drama didn’t end there. Season 3 brought another complication with Stew Ashley Marti, who despite being aware of Gary’s flirtations with others, made her own moves on him. The climax of romantic entanglements occurred in Season 4 when Gary’s careless actions led to a scandalous kiss with Daisy, triggering another love triangle involving Colin Macrae. It’s clear that Gary is often at the center of these crises, continually stirring the pot.
Legal Issues: Gary’s Liability to the Show
Time for Bravo to Move On
What is particularly shocking is Bravo’s hesitance to sever ties with Gary, especially in light of his recent lawsuit. In the aftermath of filming for Season 4, Gary faced serious accusations of sexual misconduct from former Bravo employee Samantha Suarez. While the network attempted to present a united front, details of his past behavior sparked public outcry. Bravo’s response included barring him from their 2023 BravoCon event, yet Gary remained a central figure in Season 5. His denial of the allegations and claims of being edited out only heighten the network’s exposure to liability concerns.
A Call for Fresh Faces on Below Deck Sailing Yacht
Potential for an Exciting Reboot
In summary, Below Deck Sailing Yacht would benefit from introducing new faces altogether. The repetitive nature of Daisy and Gary’s disputes has become tired, overshadowing potential narratives. While Stew Danni Warren added an interesting dynamic despite her annoying presence, the unexpected return of Chase Lemacks as a formidable rival for Gary is welcomed. It may be time to retain Danni, Glenn, and possibly Chase while seeking a complete recast for the rest. This would allow the show to move forward, leaving Gary behind and focusing on more compelling storylines and characters.
For those eager to catch up, previous seasons of Below Deck Sailing Yacht are available for streaming on Peacock.