Married At First Sight Season 18 presented a challenging viewer experience, prompting discussions about the potential for transformative changes in future installments. One intriguing concept is the possibility of a season devoid of the expert panel’s public-facing role. While the cast dedicated significant effort to nurture their relationships, the involvement of experts—Dr. Pepper Schwartz, Dr. Pia Holec, and Pastor Cal Roberson—was noticeably limited this season. Viewers found their presence lacking compared to previous seasons, where the experts took a more active role in guiding couples through their relational journey.
As the participants sought to establish connections, the expectation was for the experts to offer insightful guidance during the highs and lows of their relationships. However, the diminished visibility of the expert panel sparked conversations about their efficacy in facilitating meaningful interactions. Although I genuinely appreciate their expertise, there is a growing recognition that the hypothetical reality TV drama may hinder their ability to provide valuable advice, suggesting that a reduction in their on-screen time could be beneficial.
The MAFS Experts Have Struggled for Seasons
Struggling to Create Successful Matches
Despite the cast’s engagements with the Married At First Sight experts, the limited interactions failed to yield significant clarity or support for the couples. Observing the experts grapple with consistent challenges in fostering long-lasting matches over the seasons raises critical questions. It’s become increasingly difficult to discern the value the experts add to the show, especially when their contributions are met with skepticism from both viewers and the participants.
In the wake of recent controversies, such as the cheating scandal from Season 18, it has become apparent that the experts might not possess the authoritative insights they once projected. Their intervention did not significantly alleviate the turmoil within couples nor did it facilitate effective pairing, prompting the notion that a season without them could be refreshing. While I appreciate the role they play in the show, I am eager to see a season experiment without them.
A Fresh Approach for MAFS Season 19
The Benefits of Private Counseling

Envisioning a season where the experts are not in a public-facing role challenges traditional broadcasting norms. While it may require strategic rebranding, the absence of expert visibility could refocus the show on the couples’ emotional journeys. Instead of centering narrative arcs around counseling sessions, it may be beneficial for the experts to conduct pairings and therapeutic interventions privately. This shift could foster a more genuine dialogue among couples, allowing them to navigate complex emotions without the pressures of on-screen scrutiny.
Rethinking the Role of Experts in MAFS
Potential Distraction from Genuine Interactions

While the involvement of experts is an established facet of Married At First Sight, there is a growing sentiment that their role may not be essential going forward. The performance dynamics often lead to less authentic interactions, as couples struggle to express their true feelings when under scrutiny. Private counseling sessions could facilitate deeper connections, enabling cast members to share their thoughts candidly, ultimately enhancing the authenticity and emotional depth of the narrative. This fresh perspective might be just what the show needs for a revitalizing shift.
For further insights, check out the Married At First Sight on Instagram.