Why House’s Best Season Redeemed Its Worst Offenses

House was a groundbreaking medical drama that aired for eight remarkable seasons on Fox, yet one particular season has captured the hearts of many fans—despite some elements that may frustrate viewers. Created by David Shore, the series follows the irascible Dr. Gregory House, played by Hugh Laurie, who heads the Diagnostic Medicine department at Princeton-Plainsboro Teaching Hospital in New Jersey. With a team of brilliant specialists, House tackles perplexing medical cases involving patients with obscure diseases.

Throughout its run, House received a total of 13 Primetime Emmy nominations, which includes four nominations for Outstanding Drama Series and six for Outstanding Lead Actor in a Drama Series specifically for Laurie. Ultimately, the show garnered two Emmy Awards: one for Outstanding Writing for a Drama Series for the episode “Three Stories,”penned by Shore, and another for Outstanding Directing in a Drama Series for “House’s Head.”

The initial ensemble cast of House featured notable actors such as Jennifer Morrison as Allison Cameron, Jesse Spencer as Robert Chase, and Omar Epps as Eric Foreman. Over its first few seasons, this trio adeptly navigated various medical enigmas. However, as is the case with many television shows, the cast of House evolved significantly over time.

The Frustration of Season 4: Sidelining Cameron and Chase

Original Characters Take a Backseat

Cameron with her head in her hand as Chase discusses his BDSM relationships in the House episode Love Hurts.

Following the conclusion of House’s third season, an unexpected shift occurs when House dismisses Chase, while Cameron and Foreman resign. This sets the stage for season 4, often hailed as the show’s finest season, where House searches for new team members to fill the void. Although other characters like Cameron, Chase, and Foreman continue to appear, their roles are significantly diminished. Lisa Cuddy offers Cameron a position as the senior attending physician in the emergency room, and Chase is given an opportunity to join the surgical staff, eventually leading to Foreman’s return. Nevertheless, House continues to limit the contributions of Cameron and Chase in this pivotal season.

While Jennifer Morrison and Jesse Spencer are still credited as series regulars in season 4, their participation feels more like that of recurring characters. This is a stark contrast to the impactful presence their characters had during the initial seasons. Consequently, the minimal screen time allocated to Cameron and Chase in seasons 4 and 5 can be frustrating for long-time viewers, especially given their foundational roles in the show’s earlier narrative. Yes, while the new dynamics of House’s team justify their reduced presence, it still feels like a misstep.

Forgiving the Sidelining: The Brilliance of Season 4

Highlighting House’s Best Episodes

None
None
None
None
None

Despite the setbacks concerning Cameron and Chase, it is undeniable that season 4 stands as the pinnacle of the series. The season showcases a plethora of episodes that can be deemed as quintessential television. The impressive storytelling and the introduction of new characters, such as Thirteen and Kutner, allow the narrative to shine, compensating for the absence of established characters. Even though initially jarring, these changes prove to be beneficial as they captivate the audience’s interest.

House Season 4 Cast

Role

Hugh Laurie

Dr. Gregory House

Lisa Edelstein

Dr. Lisa Cuddy

Omar Epps

Dr. Eric Foreman

Robert Sean Leonard

Dr. James Wilson

Jennifer Morrison

Dr. Allison Cameron

Jesse Spencer

Dr. Robert Chase

Olivia Wilde

Dr. Remy “Thirteen”Hadley

Kal Penn

Dr. Lawrence Kutner

Peter Jacobson

Dr. Chris Taub

Anne Dudek

Dr. Amber Volakis

Edi Gathegi

Dr. Jeffrey “Big Love”Cole

Memorable episodes like “97 Seconds,””House’s Head,”and “Wilson’s Heart”exemplify the high caliber of storytelling achieved in season 4, overshadowing its rare shortcomings. The narrative arc that explores House’s quest to form a new team is exceptionally executed, as the writers ensure the audience becomes invested in the fresh characters introduced. While change in television can often elicit negative responses from viewers, the new direction undertaken in season 4 of House is not only accepted but embraced due to its engaging plot.

Embracing Change: The Merits of New Faces

A Smart Move for the Series

Chase and Cameron on House

Initially, the sidelining of Cameron and Chase in season 4 was disheartening. After investing three seasons in their development, it felt unjust for the series to relegate these beloved characters. However, looking back, this decision has proven beneficial. The introduction of new doctors in season 4 revitalized the series and brought forth some of the most compelling narratives. Shaking up the established team can often lead to questionable outcomes, but in this case, the choices made by the writers and producers ultimately reinforced the series’ legacy.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog