The production team behind Below Deck may have made a significant casting misstep in the upcoming season 12, and I sincerely hope this does not set a precedent for future selections. With Below Deck Down Under season 3 nearing its conclusion and Below Deck season 12 set to premiere on June 2, 2025, viewers are eager to see what’s in store. While the release of the season 12 trailer has revealed some familiar faces, such as Fraser Olender returning as Chief Stew and both Deckhand Kyle Stillie and Captain Kerry Titheradge, there are seven newcomers joining the ensemble.
In contrast to previous seasons, the editing of Below Deck Down Under season 3 has seen notable enhancements. Improvements in visuals, engaging cast biographies, romantic monologues, and even a stewardess step counter have added depth to the viewing experience. These positive changes suggest that the production is attempting to innovate its style, which raises concerns regarding their current casting choices.
Why Below Deck Season 12 Should Reconsider Solène’s Casting
Lack of Relevant Experience
Among the new additions to the Below Deck cast, Solène stands out as the least experienced member. In fact, she holds the record for the lowest yachting experience among all franchise cast members. According to her Bravo Bio, Solène arrived with only 22 days of yachting experience prior to stepping on board the motoryacht St. David. During her interview, she stated that the charter aboard St. David was her very first, indicating a complete lack of practical experience.
The decision to cast someone as underqualified as Solène raises serious concerns. It signals a troubling trend in which casting directors are willing to prioritize novelty over proven expertise. If such inexperienced individuals continue to be integrated into the team, it could lead the franchise astray, shifting focus away from showcasing seasoned yacht professionals.
Possible Motivations Behind Solène’s Casting
History in Reality TV
Adding to my concerns is Solène’s prior reality television experience. She participated in season 2 of Love Island France in 2023, where she spent over seven weeks on the show and finished in third place with contestant Nicolo Ferrari. She described herself as an “Influencer”when entering the competition – a significant red flag in the context of her motivations.
This background suggests that Solène may be leveraging her role on Below Deck merely as a platform to gain fame and expand her social media following, rather than genuinely pursuing a career in yachting. Her previous actions and current trajectory create the impression that her primary goal is self-promotion.
A Call for Improved Casting Standards
Raising Standards for Future Cast Members
It’s essential for Below Deck producers to re-evaluate their casting strategy. Hiring individuals like Solène, who lack the necessary experience and are more focused on building their public persona, detracts from the show’s reputation and the portrayal of the yachting industry. While I recognize that every professional must start somewhere, the motivations behind Solène’s casting leave much to be desired.
As Below Deck season 12 prepares to air on June 2 at 9 p.m. EDT on Bravo, I strongly believe the franchise should focus on enhancing the quality of its cast. This will not only preserve the show’s integrity but also ensure that viewers see a realistic depiction of life aboard a yacht.
Source: Bravo.com