The dynamics of László and Erzsébet’s relationship stand as a cornerstone of The Brutalist. Throughout the film, despite facing numerous marital struggles, it is evident that László deeply cares for his wife, Erzsébet. Their separation due to World War II, which forced them into different concentration camps, sets a backdrop of longing and loss. Ultimately, László’s immigration to America occurs alone, leaving Erzsébet to join him only in the latter half of the narrative. Nevertheless, her character emerges as a pivotal figure in the film, embodying the intricate themes it addresses.
The Brutalist delves into profound themes such as survival, trauma, and the immigrant experience shaped by the devastating impact of World War II. Under the astute direction of Brady Corbet, the film poignantly illustrates how both László and Erzsébet grapple with their new lives in America, haunted by the atrocities they endured during the war. By the conclusion, the couple finds solace and resolves their marital conflicts, yet Erzsébet’s struggles—particularly her battle with osteoporosis—remain a powerful narrative thread.
Erzsébet’s Condition: A Wheelchair and Osteoporosis
The Reality of Erzsébet’s Wheelchair Use
In the film’s opening half, László and Erzsébet maintain a correspondence through letters. However, her arrival in America does not occur until the story progresses. When they finally reunite at the train station, László is taken aback to see Erzsébet in a wheelchair. In her letters, she chose not to disclose her struggle with osteoporosis, a condition she developed as a consequence of severe malnutrition in the concentration camp during the war. This pivotal detail underscores the physical and emotional toll the Holocaust exacted on its survivors.
Osteoporosis is a medical condition that leads to fragile and brittle bones, posing a significant risk of fractures from trivial incidents. Due to her delicate state resulting from the malnutrition endured during her imprisonment, even slight missteps could lead to serious injuries for Erzsébet. The implications of osteoporosis extend beyond the physical realm, encompassing chronic pain and discomfort, rendering it a challenging affliction to endure.
The Origins of Erzsébet’s Osteoporosis
The Development of Osteoporosis Amidst the Holocaust
Initially, László’s shock at seeing Erzsébet in a wheelchair highlights the drastic changes wrought by the Holocaust. Prior to the war, she did not suffer from osteoporosis. Her fragile state emerged directly due to inadequate nutrition while imprisoned in a concentration camp, leading to weakened bones. This reality resonates with numerous Holocaust survivors who faced long-term health consequences following their release. Thus, while they survived the Holocaust physically, they carried indelible scars that served as constant reminders of their traumas.
While Erzsébet’s osteoporosis symbolizes their shared trauma, the couple endeavors to navigate this challenge side by side. Although osteoporosis currently has no definitive cure, individuals can adopt lifestyle changes to potentially strengthen their bones. This journey is depicted in The Brutalist, as Erzsébet gradually becomes more resilient in the years following the Holocaust and her reintegration into American life.
Erzsébet’s Triumph: Walking Without Support
Erzsébet’s Transformation by The Brutalist’s Conclusion
Remarkably, by the film’s conclusion, Erzsébet demonstrates sufficient strength to walk unaided, marking a poignant milestone in her recovery. Although she faces challenges, the scene where she walks during her confrontation with Harrison exemplifies her resilience. Through this moment, Erzsébet embodies the potential for recovery and strength, effectively illustrating that overcoming obstacles—even those as daunting as osteoporosis—is possible.