Warning! This article contains SPOILERS for the finale of Season 2 of 1923, titled “A Dream and a Memory.” In a poignant conclusion to Season 2, Jacob Dutton (Harrison Ford) made a memorable connection with Alexandra (Julia Schlaepfer), describing her as “If a shooting star could talk.”The season’s finale was laced with tragedy, marking the demise of five principal characters, including Alexandra. Her harrowing voyage from England to America culminated in a heartbreaking ending; although she welcomed John Dutton II into the world, Alexandra succumbed to frostbite and never had the chance to meet most of her husband’s family.
Jacob was the only Dutton, apart from Spencer (Brandon Sklenar), who had the opportunity to meet Alexandra. After rushing her to the hospital and unsuccessfully urging her to undergo life-saving surgery, Jacob conveyed the heartbreaking news to Cara (Helen Mirren) about the niece-in-law she would never meet. He expressed his belief that Cara would have adored Alexandra, portraying her as “mustang wild”alongside his previous description of her spirit as akin to a talking shooting star. While this flattery was evident, the exact message Jacob intended to convey about Alexandra remained somewhat ambiguous. Nevertheless, it encapsulated her essence, even though Jacob’s acquaintance with her lasted only a few hours.
Why Jacob Dutton Described Alex As “If A Shooting Star Could Talk” In 1923
Alexandra’s Radiant Spirit: Witty, Bright, and Unforgettable
Jacob’s choice to liken Alexandra to a talking shooting star stands as a testament to her vibrant personality. Throughout her brief time, Alexandra exhibited a flair for clever banter and witty exchanges that often eluded the understanding of the Dutton men. Spencer regularly remarked on his confusion regarding her humorous references, while Jacob was astonished by her ability to maintain her comedic spirit even on her deathbed. This metaphorical description of Alexandra suggests she was not only intelligent but also captivating, full of energy, and magnificently unpredictable.
Alexandra’s adventurous life further emphasized this analogy. She opted to leave behind an arranged marriage to pursue a passionate journey across Africa with an American man. Her spirited remarks highlighted her zest for life, as she expressed a refusal to be confined by physical limitations; for her, the thrill of running through fields surpassed her imagination. Despite her life being tragically short, Alexandra lived fervently, making her eventual demise all the more poignant. Jacob recognized and appreciated this brilliance, even in her final moments.
The Impact of Alexandra’s Death on the Dutton Family
A Loss of Love and Light for the Duttons
While Alexandra’s death at the conclusion of 1923 is tragic and heartbreaking in itself, its repercussions extend far beyond her loss. Spencer is now deprived of his soulmate, while John II will grow up without the warmth and nurturing presence of his mother. Furthermore, the couple may have aspired to expand their family, adding to the Dutton legacy—possibilities that are now extinguished, reinforced by Elsa Dutton’s narration indicating that Spencer never remarried.
Alexandra’s absence also resonates deeply with other members of the Dutton clan. Her wit and charm would have undoubtedly added vibrancy to the Dutton lodge, enhancing the dynamics for Cara, who would have delighted in finding a conversational equal in Alexandra. Jacob’s later life could have been enriched by Alexandra’s adventurous spirit, contributing to a more engaging retirement. A different outcome may have emerged if Alexandra had lived, potentially influencing Elizabeth’s decisions regarding her future after Jack’s death, providing the culture and sophistication she sought. Ultimately, the narrative of the Dutton family would have been dramatically altered for the better had Alexandra survived her ordeal in 1923.