While the future of The Bondsman appears to be shrouded in uncertainty, fans hungry for more supernatural adventures can explore a selection of comparable series. The supernatural genre is rich with narratives featuring characters who defy death and battle demons, and while The Bondsman may not break new ground, it skillfully weaves together familiar themes and storylines with its distinct ensemble. This unique twist makes it stand out, even as it borrows elements from other successful shows and films within the genre.
Notably, The Bondsman delivers a consistently engaging viewing experience, thanks in part to its talented cast, which breathes life into their roles. The blend of horror, comedy, and action keeps the storyline dynamic and immersive. Consequently, as the first season draws to a close, audiences are left yearning for more. Luckily for those who enjoy supernatural narratives, the wealth of similarities shared with other series means that finding a new show to engage with is an easy task.
5. Stan Against Evil
2016–2018
Featuring a talented ensemble including John C. McGinley, Janet Varney, Nate Mooney, and Deborah Baker Jr., Stan Against Evil aired for two seasons from 2016 to 2017. Although its run was cut short, the show distinguished itself within the horror genre with its campy humor, remarkable visuals, and heartfelt performances. Similar to the premise in The Bondsman, Stan goes to great lengths to defend his town from spirits, witches, and demons.
Critically, Stan Against Evil has received a positive reception, celebrated for its unabashed silliness and playful tone. Though it doesn’t venture into groundbreaking territory, this quality makes it an ideal selection for viewers seeking light-hearted supernatural entertainment.
4. Dead Boy Detectives
2024
As an extension of Netflix’s Sandman universe, Dead Boy Detectives garnered acclaim from both viewers and critics, proudly holding a high score of 92% on Rotten Tomatoes. However, despite its success, it was canceled following its inaugural season. Within its self-contained storyline, Dead Boy Detectives presents a rich supernatural narrative that balances mystery and dark humor, making it deserving of recognition.
This Netflix series is more procedural in approach compared to The Bondsman, yet it intricately explores themes ranging from the depths of the underworld to the mechanics of demonic corporate entities. Despite its unfortunate cancellation due to low viewership, there remains hope for revival if it captures enough attention.
3. Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency
2016–2017
Based on Douglas Adams’ celebrated works, Dirk Gently’s Holistic Detective Agency aired for two seasons before its untimely cancellation. The narrative centers on Todd Brotzman (played by Elijah Wood) and Farah Black (Jade Eshete) as they tackle supernatural mysteries while uncovering interconnected conspiracies. Like The Bondsman, this series employs a classic monster-of-the-week format, introducing escalating supernatural threats with each episode.
2. Preacher
2016–2019
Adapted from the acclaimed comic book series by Garth Ennis and Steve Dillon, Preacher follows Jesse Custer, a former criminal who returns to his hometown to honor a promise made to his father. However, things take a supernatural turn when he acquires a mysterious power, leading him on a journey with ex-girlfriend Tulip and Irish wanderer Cassidy to seek out God while confronting enigmatic supernatural beings.
In comparison to The Bondsman, Preacher delves deeper into character development and narrative complexity. It features morally gray characters navigating a supernatural landscape, maintaining high storytelling standards throughout its four-season run, rarely falling into redundancy.
1. Ash vs Evil Dead
2015–2018
Receiving an impressive Rotten Tomatoes rating of 99%, Ash vs Evil Dead ranks among the finest supernatural series ever produced. Bruce Campbell returns to his iconic role as Ash Williams, battling an array of otherworldly threats with his trusty chainsaw.