The Secret of Me: A Journey of Identity and Revelation
At the heart of *The Secret of Me* lies the poignant story of Jim Ambrose, who spent his early years as Kristi. As he addresses the audience directly, he clarifies a pivotal aspect of his identity: he is not transgender; rather, he is intersex. This realization came to him at the age of 19 when he uncovered the truth about his birth. Jim learned he was born with male chromosomes and ambiguous genitalia, undergoing surgery in infancy that led him to be raised as a girl.
Timely Exploration of Intersex Issues
Directed by Grace Hughes-Hallett, making her feature film debut, *The Secret of Me* offers a clear and engaging narrative through Jim’s firsthand experiences. The documentary is particularly relevant amidst the ongoing debates surrounding gender identity, which face increasing scrutiny from conservative factions.
Hughes-Hallett, known for her role as a producer in the acclaimed film *Three Identical Strangers* (2018), captures themes of identity and the repercussions of societal interventions. Similar to her previous work, *The Secret of Me* employs a straightforward storytelling technique, effectively conveying the profound implications of experimental medical practices on individual lives.
Personal Reflections and Historical Context
In his college years during 1995, Jim happened upon a significant case study by John Money, a controversial psychologist famed for his work on gender identity. One particular case, revolving around twin boys where one boy suffered a botched circumcision, drew Jim’s attention. Money recommended raising the affected twin as a girl, leading to a series of tragic outcomes. Jim found himself resonating with the narrative of David Reimer, who, after a turbulent journey of identity, tragically took his own life in 2004.
Hughes-Hallett skillfully intertwines Jim’s personal journey with interviews and historical footage, including insights into Money’s methods. Jim’s calm and sincere demeanor invites viewers into his story as he articulates the profound pain caused by his early medical treatments. After discovering his medical history, he described the initial surgery as “mutilation,” reflecting on the deceit behind his upbringing and the compounded trauma it caused.
Parental Choices and the Legacy of Dr. Money
In poignant archival footage, Jim’s parents discuss their adherence to what they believed was the best medical advice. They acknowledge Jim’s anger and confusion—emotions that resonate with viewers. Jim recalls his thoughts poignantly: “You cut my genitals out. What did you think was going to happen?” It was only after undergoing a double mastectomy and the removal of surgically constructed genitalia that Jim felt he could finally align with his true self.
The treatment trajectory Jim faced mirrors the controversial practices espoused by John Money, who argued that gender identity could be molded through socialization. His insistence on concealing the truth from children undergoing similar treatments has had far-reaching implications, affecting numerous individuals globally. The film juxtaposes Jim’s narrative with essential archival footage of an adult David Reimer, who articulately refutes the so-called “success”of Money’s theories.
Perspectives from Experts and Activists
The documentary incorporates interviews with various experts, including Tiger Devore, an intersex activist and former intern of Money, and journalist John Colapinto, who played a pivotal role in exposing the unethical practices associated with Money’s work. Their insights add depth to the narrative, showcasing the broader implications of Jim’s story.
A Few Missed Notes
While the film generally excels, it does have its flaws. The musical score occasionally disrupts the tone—particularly jarring sequences featuring a tinkling piano alongside suspenseful undertones during tense moments. Moreover, the climactic encounter between Jim and Dr. Richard Carter, the surgeon involved in his childhood treatment, feels overly staged, diminishing the heartfelt charge of the moment. Although Carter offers an apology, the orchestrated nature of their meeting contrasts with the film’s earnestness. What should have been a poignant conclusion instead emerges as an anticlimactic moment.
Conclusion: An Impactful Narrative
Despite its shortcomings, *The Secret of Me* remains a compelling exploration of identity, trauma, and self-discovery. The film’s strength lies in its authentic portrayal of Jim’s journey, offering a necessary commentary on the treatment of intersex individuals and the consequences of societal interventions.