Warning: SPOILERS for the Season 2 Finale of 1923, titled “A Dream and a Memory.”
Taylor Sheridan’s captivating prequel series, 1923, has reached its conclusion, culminating in the revelation of a long-held mystery surrounding the Dutton family lineage. As the Yellowstone franchise continues to expand with additional prequel narratives, we delve deeper into the rich history that surrounds the Dutton family saga. While we are aware of the family’s trek to Montana in 1883 and the poignant ending of Yellowstone, numerous details remain that help to craft a fuller image of this storied family.
At the forefront of this saga is Kevin Costner’s John Dutton III, a pivotal character in the Yellowstone series and arguably the most iconic representation of Taylor Sheridan’s vision. As a direct descendant of James Dutton from 1883, John Dutton III embodies the essence of the Dutton legacy. The first season of 1923 introduced us to John Dutton I, who met an untimely end, while flashbacks in Yellowstone allowed viewers a glimpse into the life of John Dutton II during his final moments. Until now, the true parentage of John Dutton II remained a tantalizing mystery.
The Season 2 Finale Unveils John Dutton II’s Origin
Discovering the Grandparents of Kevin Costner’s John Dutton III
The conclusion of 1923 Season 2 is marked by tragedy. Although Spencer manages to heroically save Alex from a perilous situation, she ultimately succumbs to complications in a hospital after giving birth to their son. This heart-wrenching moment underscores the sacrifice made by Alexandra Dutton for the birth of John Dutton II, which resolves the ongoing mystery surrounding his lineage. Prior to this, John Dutton II’s parentage hinged on the potential pairing of Spencer and Alex or Jack and Elizabeth, adding layers of intrigue to the narrative.
In Season 2, it was also revealed that Elizabeth was pregnant, suggesting that her child could potentially become John Dutton II. This theory resonated, especially considering Jack’s lineage to John Dutton I, who might favor naming his son after his father. However, with Jack’s untimely death and Elizabeth’s departure from the Dutton ranch, the responsibility of raising John Dutton II now falls to Spencer, Cara, and Jacob, ensuring the continuity of the Dutton legacy amidst the aftermath of their conflicts with Donald Whitfield and Banner Creighton.
The Connection Between John Dutton II and Kevin Costner’s Character
Flashbacks Featuring John Dutton II in Yellowstone
As noted, John Dutton II is established as the father of Kevin Costner’s character, John Dutton III. While the narrative surrounding him has yet to be explored in a dedicated series, fans have been treated to brief glimpses of his character in Yellowstone. The character, portrayed by Dabney Coleman, only appears during significant moments, specifically the day of his death, where John III is seen by his side in a poignant farewell amidst the majestic mountains of their ranch. Given his birth in 1923, he would have reached approximately 80 years of age when he passed away.