The New Wicked Prequel Aims to Connect the Book and Musical Yet Contradicts Both Narratives

Wicked has transcended its origins as a stage play to become a cultural phenomenon, now further magnified by its adaptation into a blockbuster film. While the musical has been delighting audiences on Broadway and the West End since 2003, a new prequel novel adds another layer to the lore inspired by L. Frank Baum’s classic works. Directed by Jon M. Chu, the upcoming film adaptation has broadened the reach of this captivating story, allowing it to enchant an even larger audience.

To fully appreciate the intricate narrative of Wicked, one must explore the original Baum novels, written between 1900 and 1920. These books introduced readers to the world of Oz, its diverse inhabitants, and iconic characters, including the Wicked Witch of the West. Wicked delves into the backstory of the Wicked Witch, portraying the tragic events that turn her against the people of Oz. Gregory Maguire’s latest novel, Elphie: A Wicked Childhood, aims to deepen this exploration and connect the musical to its literary roots.

Gregory Maguire’s New Wicked Prequel: Bridging Book and Musical

Maguire’s Elphie Novel Broadens the Wicked Lore

Elphaba and Glinda in the Wicked Movie
Elphaba looking concerned
Idina Menzel as Elphaba
Elphaba and Glinda embracing

Elphie: A Wicked Childhood serves as a prequel that seeks to weave a coherent narrative tapestry. The film adaptation takes significant liberties with Baum’s original texts, providing a swift yet intense backstory for Elphaba. In contrast, Maguire’s novel endeavors to create connections and elaborate on the Witch’s character, showcasing her frequent singing—an element present, albeit sparingly, in the original works. The novel also sets the groundwork for Elphaba’s magic, delivers insights into Melena Thropp’s complicated past, and elucidates pivotal details such as The Dress.

Elphie: Divergences in Wicked’s Narrative

Connecting Threads: A Murky Intersection of Stories

Glinda preparing Elphaba
Jonathan Bailey in Wicked
Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba
Boq and Nessarose dancing
Ariana Grande singing in Wicked

In Elphie, Melena’s backstory undergoes significant reconfiguration, painting her motives and personality in stark contrast to the musical. Whereas the musical presents her as a party-loving character, the book portrays Melena as unfaithful and promiscuous without reliance on substance abuse. Additionally, the novel introduces new settings like Quadling Country, absent from both the original texts and the musical.

Maguire’s portrayal of Elphaba and her sister Nessarose also diverges from the established narrative. In this version, Nessa seems to struggle with limited mobility as a child, a detail that doesn’t align with her character in the musical. Elphaba’s early interactions, including the depiction of her first words, challenge established perceptions, muddling the character’s continuity.

Navigating Between Diverging Narratives

The Challenge of Bridging Two Stories

Ariana Grande as Glinda
Cynthia Erivo as Elphaba
Elphaba and Glinda together
Jonathan Bailey quoted in Wicked
Untitled image of Wicked

Despite the complexities arising from this multifaceted narrative connection, the effort to fuse these redacted histories is commendable. Considering the century-long legacy of Baum’s original works, Maguire’s challenge is not trivial. While Wicked: The Life and Times of the Wicked Witch of the West, the inaugural novel from 1995, took time to gain traction, the musical adaptation has quickly carved out its own identity, often deviating from the source material.

Maguire strives to bridge these narrative gaps while crafting a tale that stands independently. The novel’s decisions on which elements to preserve or alter are indicative of a delicate balancing act between honoring the original works and crafting a fresh narrative. Ultimately, Elphie: A Wicked Childhood emerges as a remarkable addition to this expanding universe, inviting readers to re-examine notions of identity and storytelling.

Source&Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog