The abrupt cancellation of So Help Me Todd by CBS, leaving fans hanging on a cliffhanger, has sparked considerable frustration. Despite the uproar from the audience regarding CBS’s multiple cancellations in 2025—including popular titles like Blue Bloods, S.W.A.T., and two spinoffs of FBI—it seems that the network’s decision might have been financially motivated. The demise of So Help Me Todd in 2024 after just two seasons was particularly disheartening, especially since it was poised to delve deeper into potentially ground-breaking storylines that could have reshaped its narrative scope.
The season one finale marked a pivotal moment as Todd (played by Skylar Astin) saw his mother, Margaret (portrayed by Marcia Gay Harden), elevated to a named partner at Crest, Folding & Wright. However, by the conclusion of the second season, it was unveiled that Margaret had unwittingly become a pawn in an embezzlement scheme orchestrated by Merritt Folding (Joe Pantoliano). This development hinted at his transformation into a primary antagonist, setting the stage for a riveting season three. Unfortunately, this climax was overshadowed by the disappointment of the show’s cancellation.
Why So Help Me Todd’s Cancellation Was Divisive
A Unique Procedural Experience
Viewer backlash is common in the wake of a show’s cancellation, but So Help Me Todd garnered attention for its witty humor and fresh take on the procedural genre. Combining elements of investigation with courtroom drama, it offered a unique narrative approach that set it apart from other series. The ongoing conflict between Todd and Margaret over case-handling methods introduced dynamic complexities to the storyline, consistently engaging audiences.
Beyond the investigative elements, the central theme of family relationships deepened as the show progressed. So Help Me Todd emerged as a standout example within its genre by emphasizing familial ties; it was one of the rare procedurals that celebrated such dynamics. Viewers were able to connect with characters like Margaret, Allison (Madeline Wise), and Susan (Inga Schlingmann), who navigated their personal struggles in ways that resonated with an audience experiencing similar situations.
CBS’s Strategic Programming Moves Following Cancellation
New Opportunities Through Timeslot Adjustment
Despite a loyal fanbase, So Help Me Todd faced challenges in ratings compared to its replacement shows. According to TVLine, the timeslot formerly occupied by So Help Me Todd experienced an impressive 55% increase in viewership after CBS moved Matlock into that position. Viewers were drawn to Matlock‘s compelling conspiracy narrative, which had been captivating since its inception.
This boost in ratings spilled over into the hour prior to Elsbeth, as increased viewership contributed to a 5% uptick in its overall ratings this season. Given that Elsbeth is already in the top 10 shows with about 7.7 million viewers, that seemingly minor increase translates to a large audience impact. Fans of Elsbeth can feel reassured that the show is receiving ample attention thanks to the strategic programming changes that followed So Help Me Todd’s cancellation. Nonetheless, there remains a notable void left by its absence.
The Demand for a Similar Show on CBS
Potential for Revival or Replacement
In response to the show’s cancellation, fans have rallied around petitions advocating for the revival of So Help Me Todd. It’s not surprising, especially when TVInsider reports that there were plans for storylines stretching through to season seven. However, the petition seems to have garnered significantly fewer signatures compared to the viewership boost seen by CBS’s new programming, making a revival unlikely.
Although upcoming series such as the Blue Bloods spinoff Boston Blue may not fill the gap, CBS has other upcoming changes, with S.W.A.T. and FBI: Most Wanted also shifting timeslots. This provides an opportunity to introduce another series that follows in the footsteps of So Help Me Todd, filled with humor and family-centered storytelling. The network already has a lineup of serious procedural dramas, so a show that presents a refreshing tone would contribute positively to CBS’s offerings.
Source: TVLine, TVInsider
Enjoy ScreenRant’s primetime coverage? Click below to sign up for our weekly Network TV newsletter (ensure to check “Network TV”in your preferences) and receive exclusive insights from actors and showrunners about your favorite series.
SIGN UP NOW