Chicago Justice represented the fourth installment of the popular One Chicago franchise, created by renowned television producer Dick Wolf. Unfortunately, the series was short-lived, concluding after just one season. During its run in 2017, it struggled to find an audience, ultimately ranking as the lowest-rated entry within the franchise. This was surprising, considering it performed better than other NBC programs at the time, such as Taken and Shades of Blue, both of which were renewed after their inaugural seasons. Following the successes of shows centering around firefighters, police officers, and medical professionals, it was a natural step for Wolf and his team to introduce a legal drama featuring Chicago attorneys.
Chicago Justice and Its Connection to One Chicago
Justice: The Franchise’s Fourth Series
Set against the backdrop of the windy city, Chicago Justice stars Philip Winchester as Assistant State’s Attorney Peter Stone. Stone is the son of the legendary New York Assistant District Attorney Benjamin Stone, a character from the earlier seasons of Law & Order. As a driven and astute attorney, Peter’s quest is not solely to uphold his father’s esteemed legacy but also to ensure that perpetrators are brought to justice. Notably, he has a history of implicating Sergeant Hank Voight, a central character from the franchise, in past misconduct.
The pilot episode for Chicago Justice was introduced during the third season of Chicago P.D., where Stone and his team endeavor to unearth vital evidence to exonerate Detective Kim Burgess concerning a case linked to a teenage assailant. The talented cast also includes Monica Barbaro as Assistant State’s Attorney Anna Valdez, who serves as Stone’s diligent partner. Valdez constantly learns from Stone as they tackle various legal challenges together. Jon Seda, reprising his role as Antonio Dawson after exiting Chicago P.D., joins the cast as Chief Investigator, teaming up with Laura Nagel, portrayed by Joelle Carter, who also has a background in law enforcement.
The series features Cook County State’s Attorney Mark Jefferies, portrayed by the late Carl Weathers. The narrative explores a range of intense cases, touching on themes of murder, arson, and kidnapping while also showcasing appearances from familiar One Chicago characters. These include Officer Kevin Atwater, who becomes embroiled in a controversy over perceived excessive force, and Sylvie Brett, who rekindles a romance with Dawson while navigating a murder investigation involving an anti-environmental politician. The show also delves into the personal struggles of its characters, notably exploring Nagel’s battle to reclaim custody of her daughter amidst an addiction crisis.
Reasons Behind NBC’s Cancellation of Chicago Justice
Chicago Justice’s Challenges: Similarities and Scheduling Issues
Despite having a procedural structure that deftly combines character-driven narratives with thrilling criminal cases, Chicago Justice faced cancellation after just one season. Critics noted its striking similarities to the established Law & Order franchise, where investigators and attorneys routinely engage in trials of justice. Although the series premiered with promising ratings, viewer numbers dwindled throughout the season, ultimately persuading NBC to withdraw support. The network determined that the show did not possess enough distinctiveness to thrive independently when juxtaposed with the longstanding Law & Order series.
|
Character |
Actor |
|---|---|
|
Peter Stone |
Philip Winchester |
|
Antonio Dawson |
Jon Seda |
|
Laura Nagel |
Joelle Carter |
|
Anna Valdez |
Monica Barbaro |
|
Mark Jefferies |
Carl Weathers |
Additionally, Chicago Justice struggled due to its scheduling on Sunday nights, contrasting with the successful mid-week time slots of its One Chicago counterparts, such as Chicago Fire, Chicago Med, and Chicago P.D.. The show had to compete not only with these established programs but also with other new series, including the sci-fi drama Timeless. Although it achieved better ratings than many other rookie NBC shows, the network deemed it too formulaic and positionally redundant when compared to the stronger existing entries in the franchise.
Post-Cancellation Developments for Chicago Justice Characters
Potential for Character Development in One Chicago
After the cancellation of Chicago Justice, Antonio Dawson was reintegrated into the Intelligence unit of Chicago P.D., reuniting with familiar faces such as Hank Voight and other colleagues within the Chicago police force. Peter Stone then transitioned to Law & Order: SVU, where he had appeared previously, grappling with the loss of his father in collaboration with Olivia Benson and ADA Jack McCoy. Adjusting to the environment in New York was a significant shift for Stone, particularly after ADA Rafael Barba’s departure, yet he formed a productive working partnership with Benson.
While a return of the characters from Chicago Justice to the wider One Chicago narrative seems unlikely, it remains a tantalizing possibility that their stories could be revisited in some capacity.
The fates of Valdez, Nagel, and Jefferies remain uncertain, but it’s likely they continue their pursuit of justice in the city of Chicago. These characters could have thrived in crossovers with other One Chicago entries, allowing them to collaborate with the Intelligence unit. Especially for Stone, there exists a wealth of untapped narrative potential, particularly considering his evolving dynamic with Benson, who provided crucial emotional support to him after a family tragedy. While a full revival seems improbable, there are still opportunities for these characters to make impactful reappearances in future story arcs.
If you’re a fan of ScreenRant’s primetime analysis, consider subscribing to our weekly Network TV newsletter. Just click below and ensure you check off “Network TV”in your preferences to stay updated on the latest insights from actors and showrunners regarding your favorite programs!