While Sylvester Stallone’s portrayal of Rocky Balboa has been pivotal to the Creed franchise, I believe it’s time for the character to step away from the spotlight. After Stallone’s memorable performance in Rocky Balboa (2006), the series was reinvigorated by Creed in 2015. In this iteration, Rocky transitioned from the fighter to a mentor, guiding Adonis Creed and embracing a more paternal role. This film is often regarded as the finest entry in the series, paving the way for subsequent sequels.
Notably, Stallone’s absence from Creed III raised eyebrows, particularly given his significant involvement in the previous two installments. The success of this third film has since led to the announcement of Creed IV, which Michael B. Jordan is set to direct. Despite the anticipation surrounding the new installment, it’s increasingly likely that Stallone will not reprise his role. Although some loyal fans are disappointed by this, I contend that Rocky’s presence isn’t essential for the forthcoming narrative.
The Future of Rocky Balboa in Creed: Likely Gone for Good
Stallone’s Divergent Views on the Direction of the Franchise
Though Rocky played a pivotal role in the first two Creed films, Stallone chose not to participate in Creed III. The actor has expressed feelings that the film’s darker themes strayed too far from the essence of the franchise. In an interview with Variety, he remarked:
It was taken in a direction that is quite different than I would’ve taken it. It’s a different philosophy — Irwin Winkler’s and Michael B. Jordan’s. I wish them well, but I’m much more of a sentimentalist. I like my heroes getting beat up, but I just don’t want them going into that dark space. I just feel people have enough darkness.
Alongside creative differences with Irvin Winkler, the long-time producer of the Rocky series, Stallone has faced personal grievances regarding the rights to the franchise. After monetarily struggling, Stallone sold the rights to Winkler prior to the original film’s release. While the franchise attained extraordinary success, Stallone remains without any ownership, and the sustained tension between the two has largely precluded his potential return.
The Perfect Farewell: Rocky’s Journey in Creed II
A Fitting Exit for Rocky in Creed II
Rocky’s narrative has been a roller-coaster of triumphs and hardships. After losing his wife Adrian and becoming estranged from his son Robert in earlier films, he experiences a renaissance in Rocky Balboa (2006) by reconnecting with Robert during his final fight preparation. Stallone’s character received closure in this film, but his journey continued through the Creed sequels.
In Creed II, Rocky faces familiar challenges, reestablishing a connection with Robert, who is now a father himself. Following Adonis’s victory over Viktor Drago, Rocky gracefully steps away from the ring, stating, “It’s your time,”and ventures off to reconnect with his family. This plotline embodies a sense of fulfillment, making Rocky’s potential return unnecessary.
Embracing Rocky’s Absence: A New Era for Creed
Preserving Rocky’s Legacy: The Case Against His Return
Considering the satisfying conclusion provided in Creed II and Stallone’s ongoing conflict with Winkler, I feel Rocky’s absence from Creed IV is a fitting choice. Disappointing as it may be for some enthusiasts, there is little incentive for Stallone to resume his iconic role since his character has reached a natural endpoint. Furthermore, his involvement could jeopardize the rich legacy left behind.
| Every Rocky/Creed Movie | RT Critics Score |
|---|---|
| Rocky (1976) | 93% |
| Rocky II (1979) | 70% |
| Rocky III (1982) | 65% |
| Rocky IV (1985) | 39% |
| Rocky V (1990) | 32% |
| Rocky Balboa (2006) | 78% |
| Creed (2015) | 95% |
| Creed II (2018) | 83% |
| Creed III (2023) | 89% |
Moreover, the commercial and critical success of Creed III demonstrates the franchise’s ability to thrive independently of Stallone’s involvement. With a higher Rotten Tomatoes score compared to Creed II, as reported by Rotten Tomatoes, it’s clear that the series can excel without his character. In summary, while Stallone’s discontent with the franchise direction and his ongoing disputes with Winkler are regrettable, I believe Rocky’s departure from the Creed narrative is a healthy step forward.
Source: Variety