Warning: This article contains spoilers for S.W.A.T. season 8, episode 18.
As the series S.W.A.T. approaches its finale, the departure of original characters has begun, with significant implications for the storyline. In the latest episode, Commander Hicks, portrayed by Patrick St. Esprit, has made the pivotal decision to resign from his position rather than accept a reassignment. This marks a significant moment in season 8, particularly noting that there will be no ninth season to explore this development.
The Impetus Behind Hicks’ Resignation
Deputy Chief Bennett (Merrin Dungey) has clarified that the decision to transfer Hicks to the art theft unit stems from a desire to introduce new leadership into the S.W.A.T. team. Despite Hicks’ proven track record and willingness to adapt, he’s perceived as a relic of an older generation. This perception is puzzling given his history of innovation and support for his team, notably when he promoted Hondo (Shemar Moore) over Deacon (Jay Harrington) for the benefit of the community.
Despite Hicks’ contributions, Bennett has persuaded the upper management at the L.A.P.D. to implement changes, leading to Hicks’ resignation. It’s implied that she has a list of potential replacements, possibly including Hondo. Interestingly, Bennett seemed unfazed by Hicks’ decision to step down, hinting at her ambivalence towards his leadership.
The Call for New Leadership Overshadowed by Cancellation
If a season 9 had been in the works, the narrative around new blood entering the team could have been compelling. Viewers might have witnessed the impact of new leadership on team dynamics and addressed initial conflicts, such as the differing training methods advocated by Tan (David Lim) that Deacon found troubling. This perspective might have allowed for a more thorough exploration of character relationships and group progress.
Regrettably, the cancellation of S.W.A.T. leaves these developments unrealized. With only three episodes remaining until the series concludes, there is insufficient time to introduce new leadership and fully investigate its ramifications. This renders Hicks’ storyline unsatisfactory, as viewers are deprived of witnessing a meaningful departure for an established character. Furthermore, if Hondo had attempted to reinstate Hicks, the entire storyline would feel inconsequential when more time could have been allocated to complete each character’s journey.
The Importance of Closure in the Series Finale
After eight immersive seasons, it is essential that the arcs of prominent characters reach a satisfying conclusion. Showrunner Andrew Dettmann has expressed his intention for the finale to convey a sense of ongoing camaraderie and active cases; however, personal storylines must also find resolution. Fans deserve a payoff for their continued support and investment in these characters’ lives.
Given that S.W.A.T. was cancelled during production, it would have been challenging to adapt the finale. However, minor adjustments could have been made to enhance character resolutions. This is particularly relevant for original characters like Hicks, whose arcs need to feel complete. An ideal conclusion for Hicks could have involved a retirement storyline envisaged on his terms, wrapping up his journey in a manner that honors his legacy.
While the challenges posed by the abrupt cancellation of S.W.A.T. are undeniable, the opportunity for a thoughtful and fulfilling finale still exists. Ensuring closure for characters like Hicks would resonate powerfully with the audience, leaving a lasting impact that honors the years of storytelling.