Warning: Spoilers for The Amazing Spider-Man #70!
In the realm of Spider-Man fandom, one nagging controversy continues to dominate discussions: Marvel’s ongoing refusal to rekindle the relationship between Peter Parker and Mary Jane Watson. This decision appears rooted in the consequences of the notorious “One More Day”storyline, which disrupted the trajectory of not only their romance but also the comic’s broader narrative. Marvel has consistently reaffirmed its stance, emphasizing the separation between these iconic characters.
Enter Shay Marken, who has emerged as a significant figure in Spider-Man’s life. While MJ remains an untouchable past love, Shay has offered a fresh perspective and proven to be one of the more compatible partners Peter Parker has encountered in recent years. However, with rumors of a new romantic interest surfacing, it raises concerns that Marvel might prematurely diminish this budding relationship before it has a real chance to develop.
Shay Marken: A Deeper Look into Spider-Man’s New Relationship
Shay first entered the Spider-Man narrative under the writing of Zeb Wells, serving as a caregiver for Mary-Jane’s aunt, Anna Watson, at the Ravencroft Institute for the Criminally Insane. Anna was negatively impacted by Krakoan pharmaceuticals, leading to mental health struggles. After Spider-Man alleviates Anna’s condition in X-Men #29, Anna gratefully introduces Peter to Shay, marking the beginning of a new chapter.
Despite some early dates, their relationship took off in The Amazing Spider-Man #55. This was a critical moment as the complexities of Spider-Man’s crime-fighting duties often intruded on their time together. Notably, Shay remains dedicated to her own responsibilities as well, highlighting a relatable struggle of juggling personal and professional lives. Her commitment to Peter, amidst the chaos, shows her patience and understanding.
However, Peter’s struggle to manage these dual lives leads to inevitable tensions in their relationship. Unbeknownst to Shay that Peter is Spider-Man, she feels neglected and undervalued, prompting her to advocate for her needs. This dynamic is a refreshing twist, showcasing a partner who holds Spider-Man accountable and encourages personal growth. Shay’s influence could represent a turning point for Peter, bringing much-needed balance to his life.
A Troubling Trend: Spider-Man’s Recurrent Relationship Challenges
Peter Parker’s Romantic Life Faces New Hurdles
Regrettably, the upward trajectory of Peter and Shay’s relationship was short-lived, as the end of Zeb Wells’ era left little room for further exploration. Their emotional growth was overshadowed by new writers reverting Peter to old patterns: prioritizing his Spider-Man responsibilities over his relationship. This regression is particularly evident in the ongoing “8 Deaths of Spider-Man”storyline, where Peter falters in his commitment to Shay, much to her dismay.
Despite Shay’s attempts to support Peter through his struggles, his unresponsiveness prompts her to suggest he seek help. In The Amazing Spider-Man #66, this pivotal moment seems to signal the end of their relationship. Yet, recent developments hint at their potential reconciliation, leaving fans hopeful for their future.
Marvel’s Reluctance to Let Peter Parker Settle Down: Possible Consequences
Hints of a New Romance on the Horizon
Unfortunately, the prospect of a lasting second chance for Peter Parker and Shay seems bleak. As Marvel teases a new direction for The Amazing Spider-Man, inklings of a fresh romance for Peter have begun to surface. The identity of this upcoming love interest remains shrouded in mystery, leading to fears that the publisher may undermine Shays’s role even before it fully develops.
Given Marvel’s insistence on keeping Spider-Man and Mary-Jane apart, Shay Marken has emerged as a compelling and deserving partner for Peter in his current chapter. While it might be an attempt to maintain Spider-Man’s relatability, the decision risks sidelining a relationship that has the potential to be both engaging and meaningful. Instead of prematurely disrupting this connection, Marvel should allow Spider-Man and Shay the opportunity to evolve together.
The Amazing Spider-Man #70 is now available from Marvel Comics.