The recent lackluster performance of Snow White has raised questions about Disney’s strategy for future live-action adaptations. Despite its connection to the beloved 1937 animated classic, feedback on the new film has been disappointing. Rachel Labonte from Screen Rant noted an unimpressive rating of 5 out of 10, citing the use of CGI for the dwarfs as a detracting factor, combined with an ending that many found anticlimactic. The film currently struggles with a disheartening score of 40% on Rotten Tomatoes (via Rotten Tomatoes).
In addition to poor critical reviews, Snow White has not fared well at the box office, accumulating only $169 million globally (via Box Office Mojo). Given its substantial production budget of $240 million, Disney is facing significant financial losses. This alarming trend may prompt the entertainment giant to reassess its approach toward future live-action remakes of its cherished animated classics.
Impact of Snow White’s Box Office Performance on Other Projects
Following the disappointing reception of Snow White, Disney has temporarily halted production on the live-action adaptation of Tangled. This decision appears to be a direct response to the financial setbacks expected from Snow White, which is likely to cost Disney hundreds of millions. The forthcoming Tangled film was set to revisit the beloved 2010 animated tale that holds an impressive 89% rating on Rotten Tomatoes (via Rotten Tomatoes). The story revolves around the adventure of Princess Rapunzel, who is liberated from her tower by the charming Flynn Rider.
While casting announcements had yet to be made, director Michael Gracey, renowned for his work on The Greatest Showman and the upcoming biopic Better Man, was attached to the project. Despite this setback, Disney hasn’t officially canceled the production. However, it is uncertain when work will resume, as Disney’s executives are likely reevaluating their strategy in light of Snow White’s poor box office performance.
Disney’s Recent Live-Action Remake Performance: A Trend of Declining Interest
Notable Live-Action Remakes That Underperformed
Recent performances of Disney’s live-action films reflect waning audience interest in these adaptations. Although some have enjoyed acclaim, several have struggled to meet expected box office returns. For instance, while The Little Mermaid earned $569 million, its hefty budget of $240 million limited profits for Disney.
Other titles have fared even worse; 2019’s Dumbo grossed only $353 million against a budget of $170 million. These examples signify a troubling pattern for Disney, suggesting that adaptations of their legendary animated films do not guarantee commercial success. Moreover, Disney’s recent films have often received critical backlash, frequently receiving “Rotten”ratings on Rotten Tomatoes.
Future Live-Action Remakes on Disney’s Agenda
Upcoming Releases: Lilo & Stitch and Moana
Despite halting the Tangled project, Disney is pressing ahead with other live-action remakes. The Lilo & Stitch adaptation is scheduled to premiere on May 23, 2025, followed by Moana, which is set for a July 10, 2026 release. With both films already in production and release dates confirmed, it is unlikely that Disney will postpone their rollout.
In addition to these titles, projects such as Hercules, Robin Hood, The Aristocats, and Bambi remain in development. Though production for Tangled is on hold, there is optimism that these other adaptations can move forward as scheduled. Disney’s strategy may shift as they navigate the fallout from Snow White, hoping for success with future releases like Lilo & Stitch and Moana.
A Call for Disney to Reassess Live-Action Remake Strategy
Mitigating Future Critical and Commercial Risks
There is potential for success with Lilo & Stitch and the live-action version of Moana, which would likely draw considerable box office receipts. Early glimpses from trailers indicate that Lilo & Stitch promises to deliver family-friendly entertainment. Moreover, both animated films performed strongly at the box office. The hope remains that these upcoming projects can revive Disney’s fortunes.
Nevertheless, even if these slated films perform well financially, it may be prudent for Disney to reassess and refine their strategies for live-action remakes. Snow White epitomizes a growing trend of failures within Disney’s remakes, alongside 2020’s Mulan, 2022’s Pinocchio, and the previously mentioned Dumbo. Many recent adaptations have notably failed to resonate with audiences or do justice to their animated predecessors.
Given the affection fans harbor for Disney’s animated classics, it may be wise for the company to consider pausing future projects. Taking the necessary time to rethink their approach could usher in a new era for Disney’s live-action endeavors, ensuring that they honor the legacy of the beloved animated films they are based on.