Similar to other modern shōnen manga, My Hero Academia has sparked an array of fan theories exploring diverse elements of its narrative, including the fascinating nature of Quirks and the intricate relationships among characters such as Deku, Ochako, and Himiko. After revisiting this beloved series a few months post-finale, one particular fan theory emerged as a captivating narrative alternative to one of the series’ most significant revelations.
In the latter half of the saga, a primary mystery revolved around identifying All For One’s mole within Class 1-A. This conundrum led to various theories circulating among fans, with some being rational and others straying into the realm of the absurd—ultimately none being confirmed. Intriguingly, the most compelling theory appears to align closely with the contemplations of the series creator, Kōhei Horikoshi.
The Ties That Bind: Speculative Theory Proposes Another Traitor in My Hero Academia
Aoyama’s Betrayal Raised Eyebrows Among Fans
Revealed in My Hero Academia Chapter 335, Yuga Aoyama, known as the Shining Hero: Can’t Stop Twinkling, turned out to be All For One’s infiltrator within Class 1-A. Although Aoyama’s tragic history contributed to the emotional weight of his betrayal, many fans felt that the reveal lacked the essential components of a classic “whodunit”mystery. Unlike other “traitor among us”storylines that excel in character complexity, subtle hints, and escalating tension, Aoyama’s arc largely caught audiences off guard because he was an unlikely candidate.
A particular Reddit user, @Rozonth123, posited that Aoyama may not have originally been envisioned as the mole. This assertion is built on two panels from the manga showcasing Naomasa Tsukauchi, a police detective, sporting a striped tie, mirrored in a scene featuring Kurogiri, who is wearing a similar tie. According to @Rozonth123, this striking similarity suggests a deeper narrative connection, possibly hinting at an alternate creative direction Horikoshi had considered.
The Alternate Traitor Concept Could Have Enhanced the My Hero Academia Narrative
Kurogiri as the Traitor Would Add Layers of Intrigue
Regardless of the theory’s plausibility, the notion itself presents a fascinating twist that could have greatly enriched the storyline involving the mole. Imagine the unsettling dynamic of a villain masquerading as a police officer, while the authentic officer is actively engaged in efforts to dismantle the criminal operation. Such a twist would elevate tension and suspense, as any moment could potentially expose Kurogiri’s true identity, creating a sense of urgency that was not as palpable in Aoyama’s narrative.
Moreover, the backstory surrounding Kurogiri’s infiltration would be compelling. With his warping abilities, Kurogiri might navigate spaces where Detective Tsukauchi is present, like planning sessions. Yet, the challenge of assuming human form while cloaked in his signature dark mist would present considerable storytelling hurdles. However, few are as adept as Horikoshi at weaving complex plots, suggesting this could have been an innovative narrative path.
Whether or not any obstacles arise from the “Kurogiri-as-Tsukauchi” plotline, it undeniably would introduce higher stakes, psychological resonance, and intricate storytelling elements than what we ultimately experienced. Integrating such a storyline could have transformed the fan experience and narrative depth for My Hero Academia followers.
Source: @Rozonth123