Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5 has struggled to engage its audience, raising questions about the future of the show. Many fans feel that the series might benefit from a new spin-off, especially after Gary King’s presence has impacted the show’s dynamics. While the current season hasn’t been entirely without merit, it lacks the zest and drama typically provided by well-known figures like Gary, Daisy Kelliher, and Colin Macrae. The struggles with the charter guests, the crew’s monotonous conflicts, and the overarching feeling of manufactured storylines have left viewers feeling that this season is dragging its heels.
Throughout this season, the production team has made evident attempts to distance itself from Gary, who has faced allegations of sexual misconduct that surfaced prior to the season’s beginning. Even though he has remained aboard the Parsifal III, the editing has minimized his visibility. Bravo’s strategy to downplay Gary is a direct response to viewers’ demands for his removal, but the show feels fundamentally altered since the onset of this season. Previously, Gary’s storylines were integral in showcasing his controversial behavior while also propelling the plot forward. Sadly, without this pivotal element, BDSY appears lackluster and in dire need of revitalization.
The Controversial Legacy of Gary King
The Implications of His Actions
Following the fourth season, viewers expressed concerns regarding Gary’s behaviors within the crew dynamic. Despite his competency as a yacht crew member, Gary has repeatedly exhibited unprofessional conduct, particularly towards female colleagues. This troubling behavior has intensified with each passing season, making his interactions increasingly difficult to appreciate. His tendency to stir up competition and discord among crew members, particularly the women, has detracted from the fun and camaraderie that viewers expect from the series.
The situation worsened when serious allegations against Gary emerged during the filming of Season 5. While he staunchly denies these claims, an incident involving a Below Deck makeup artist has cast his character into question, further complicating the narrative of the show. Even though these allegations remain unverified, they tarnished the previously pristine reputation of Below Deck Sailing Yacht.
The Response of Season 5 to Controversy
A Lack of Engaging Drama
Despite filming beginning with Gary still part of the crew when allegations surfaced, producers made the contentious decision to continue filming with him onboard. His contribution to the team was significant, complicating any potential removal process. As a long-term employee on Captain Glenn Shephard’s Parsifal III, eliminating Gary at this stage would prove logistically challenging.
As the editing of Season 5 progressed, it became apparent that adjustments were necessary, particularly concerning Gary’s role. His limited appearance, despite being prominently featured in trailers, signifies the show’s struggle to maintain its usual captivating narrative. The rest of the team has worked hard to fill the void; nonetheless, the show lacks the excitement viewers typically associate with the series. This has led to a consensus among fans that the current season feels stagnant and uninspiring.
Prospects for a New Spin-Off
Renewing the Franchise with a New Show
While it’s conceivable for Below Deck Sailing Yacht to undergo a much-needed transformation, the season’s challenges and cast-related struggles might be difficult to overcome. The franchise has multiple spin-off options, but a fresh Below Deck series could invigorate interest among viewers. Previous renditions have sometimes faltered, such as Below Deck Adventure, yet other spin-offs hint that viewers remain interested in the adventurous aspects of the brand.
A unique spin-off could explore the complexities of sailing yachts, which require distinct skills compared to traditional superyachts. This fresh focus could captivate viewers, showcasing an entirely different side of the yachting experience. Although there remains the possibility for Below Deck Sailing Yacht to regain its footing, introducing a new series may provide the rejuvenation the franchise desperately needs.
Below Deck Sailing Yacht airs Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo.
Source: Gary King/Instagram