Ranking the 9 Fellowship Members of The Lord of the Rings Based on Their Importance to the Quest

In The Lord of the Rings, the Fellowship of the Ring comprised nine distinct members, each playing a pivotal yet varying role in the quest to destroy Sauron’s One Ring. Their mission was clandestine, aiming to transport the Ring to Mordor, where it could be annihilated. This strategy caught the Dark Lord off guard, as he expected the inhabitants of Middle-earth to use the Ring to contend against him. Ultimately, the Fellowship succeeded, thanks to the diverse contributions of its members.

Their individual journeys brought these characters to Rivendell with varying intentions. For instance, Legolas arrived bearing the news of Gollum’s escape from Mirkwood, while Boromir sought counsel after a prophetic dream. Gimli came to consult with Elrond. None were aware that the Council of Elrond would unite their fates, but each character played a role—albeit with differing levels of significance—in the battle against Sauron.

9
Boromir

Boromir’s Role and Tragic End

None

Boromir stands out as one of the most complex characters in the Fellowship. Despite his attempt to seize the Ring from Frodo—an act driven by desperation—his contributions were nonetheless vital. He provided crucial protection for the Hobbits and, through his actions, imparted valuable lessons about the corrupting nature of the Ring on noble individuals.

However, his premature death in the saga raises questions about the comparative importance of his role to those of his companions. Boromir’s aspirations centered around bringing the Ring to Gondor, diverging from the Fellowship’s ultimate objectives. His brief tenure underscores the variance in impact among the Fellowship’s members.

8
Pippin

Pippin’s Crucial Contributions to Gondor

None

Pippin, the youngest member of the Fellowship, showcased remarkable bravery from the outset. Although his role in the primary mission to destroy the Ring was somewhat limited, Pippin’s influence significantly affected events in Gondor. Following Boromir’s demise, Pippin swore fealty to Denethor, the Steward of Gondor, which had larger implications for the war effort.

By saving Faramir, Pippin strengthened Gondor’s defenses at a crucial juncture, indirectly aiding Frodo’s quest. While Pippin himself wasn’t essential to the Ring’s destruction, his actions after Boromir’s fall enhanced the overall strength of the participants in the battle against Sauron.

7
Gimli

Gimli’s Valor in Battle

None

While not directly involved in the Ring’s destruction, Gimli’s steadfastness as a warrior was invaluable. His prowess in battle significantly bolstered the efforts of the Fellowship during critical confrontations, including the iconic fights at Helm’s Deep and the Pelennor Fields. Without these victories, Frodo’s mission might have faltered due to the chaos wrought by Sauron’s forces.

Gimli’s most notable moment came at Helm’s Deep when he, alongside Eomer, exploited a tactical advantage against Saruman’s army. This decisive action helped to hold off the overwhelming Uruk-hai, ultimately playing a crucial role in the larger conflict unfolding in Middle-earth.

6
Legolas

Legolas’ Early Impact and Ongoing Presence

None

Legolas, an elf with formidable combat skills, played a critical role in supporting both Aragorn and Gimli. His dedication to the cause ensured that he became a pivotal figure in the battles at Helm’s Deep and the Pelennor Fields. However, it was his prior history with Gollum that significantly shaped the Fellowship’s formation.

Having failed to restrain Gollum in Mirkwood, Legolas’s report about the escape was instrumental in uniting the Fellowship. Ironically, the eventual destruction of the One Ring hinged upon Gollum’s actions, demonstrating that mistakes can sometimes lead to unexpected but vital outcomes.

5
Merry

Merry’s Moment of Glory

None

Merry’s contributions were often overshadowed, much like Pippin’s, until a climactic moment during the Battle of Pelennor Fields. His courageous attack against the Witch-king of Angmar provided the window for Eowyn to strike the killing blow. Merry’s unique dagger, acquired at the Barrow-downs, was among the few weapons capable of piercing the Witch King’s spectral form.

This act was no small feat; had Merry not intervened, the outcome of the confrontation could have vastly altered the trajectory of Frodo’s quest, highlighting the importance of even the most unassuming members of the Fellowship in pivotal moments.

4
Aragorn

Aragorn’s Strategic Distraction

None

Among the Fellowship, Aragorn was undeniable in his significance. As the rightful heir to Gondor’s throne, he represented a formidable threat to Sauron, who feared that Aragorn might seize the One Ring for himself. Instead of claiming power, Aragorn utilized his position to divert Sauron’s attention.

By confronting Sauron at the Black Gate, he created an opening for Frodo to approach Mount Doom undetected. This selfless act exemplified Aragorn’s maturity and leadership, marking him as one of the Fellowship’s most integral members.

3
Sam

Sam’s Indispensable Support

None

Though Samwise Gamgee often underestimated his own value, he emerged as the backbone of Frodo’s mission. Gandalf recognized Sam’s potential long before the quest began, ensuring his place alongside Frodo. As the loyal gardener and companion, Sam’s unwavering support was critical in overcoming the psychological and physical toll of carrying the One Ring.

When Frodo faltered, it was Sam who provided the strength to push forward, ultimately even carrying Frodo up Mount Doom when the burden became too great. Sam’s love and dedication were pivotal in ensuring that Frodo reached his goal, thus solidifying his role as a cornerstone of the Fellowship’s success.

2
Gandalf

Gandalf’s Mastermind Strategy

None

Debate remains on whether Gandalf or Frodo was more crucial to the achievement against Sauron. As an Istar, Gandalf was there to guide rather than directly battle Sauron. His true genius lay in his ability to influence those around him, enabling characters like Frodo and Aragorn to shoulder the burden of the quest.

Ultimately, Gandalf’s success contrasts sharply with that of other Istari. His willingness to take a backseat empowered the true heroes of Middle-earth, a trait that underscores his role in orchestrating the Fellowship’s ultimate victory.

1
Frodo

Frodo as the Central Ring-bearer

None

Frodo Baggins, as the designated Ring-bearer, held the most critical role in the Fellowship. His companions rallied to support him as they embarked on their perilous journey across Middle-earth, acutely aware that this quest could cost Frodo his life.

Despite his heroic efforts, Frodo ultimately could not willingly cast the Ring into Mount Doom’s flames. However, through the convoluted paths of destiny, he succeeded in reaching his destination thanks to Sam and the unexpected twists of fate involving Gollum. Without Frodo’s self-sacrifice and determination, the Fellowship’s triumph in The Lord of the Rings would have remained an unattainable dream.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog