In 2018, Julien Baker, Phoebe Bridgers, and Lucy Dacus united to create their indie alternative supergroup, boygenius. Their self-titled EP, released in October of that year, marked their debut, leading to a co-headlined tour that showcased their individual talents while emphasizing their commitment to solo work. After a five-year break, where each member released a full-length album, the trio reunited in 2023 to unveil their much-anticipated LP, The Record.
Upon its release, The Record made a significant impact on the alternative and pop music scenes. Many listeners, including myself, discovered boygenius through this album, often previously familiar only with one or more of the individual artists. The twelve-track LP quickly propelled Dacus, Baker, and Bridgers to the forefront of alt-rock charts, garnering new fans along the way. Below, we rank all twelve tracks from this beloved album.
12 Without You Without Them
Track 1
The album opens with “Without You Without Them,”a brief a cappella piece showcasing the harmonious vocals of all three artists. Clocking in at just 1:21, this introductory track serves as a beautiful homage to their bond and talents, captivating listeners from the outset. While its charm lies in its simplicity, some may find it feels more like a dedication than a standout musical piece on The Record.
11 We’re In Love
Track 10
Listen here
“We’re In Love”stands as the longest track on the album, yet it’s arguably the least engaging. While the poetic lyrics, led by Lucy Dacus’ soothing vocals, create a contemplative vibe, the lack of variation in tone can render the song somewhat monotonous. The lyrics invite analysis as poetry, but the song may feel slow compared to its more dynamic counterparts.
If you rewrite your life, may I still play a part?
In the next one, will you find me?
I’ll be the boy with the pink carnation pinned to my lapel
Who looks like hell and asks for help
And if you do, I’ll know it’s you
While hauntingly beautiful, the track’s nearly five-minute length could have benefited from tighter production, as it tends to lag in comparison with more energetic offerings on the album.
10 Letter To An Old Poet
Track 12
“Letter to an Old Poet”exudes a melodic beauty but feels somewhat unrefined. Although it lacks the monotony found in “We’re In Love,”its stream-of-consciousness lyrics can leave listeners yearning for more polished storytelling. However, the pivotal line sung by Phoebe Bridgers encapsulates emotional weight:
But you’re not special, you’re evil / You don’t get to tell me to calm down.
Bridgers’ vocals emanate a poignant nostalgia, making this closing track a serene, if slightly complex, end to the album.
9 Anti-Curse
Track 11
8 Revolution 0
Track 7
Another track that struggles to stand out is “Revolution 0,”which delves into complex themes of mental illness through Bridgers’ evocative vocals. The juxtaposition of dark lyrics and a major key melody creates an intriguing contrast that is signature to boygenius’ unique sound.
7 $20
Track 2
I personally enjoy “$20,”particularly for the climactic ending featuring Julien Baker’s powerful scream. While it has a strong opening, the repetition in its refrain may lessen its impact. The second half of the song feels entrapped in a looping structure, though its initial momentum justifies the ride.
6 Emily I’m Sorry
Track 3
Listen here
One of the album’s lead singles, “Emily I’m Sorry”captivates with its harmonious chorus that highlights all three members’ vocal strengths. Transitioning seamlessly from the intensity of “$20,”this heartfelt ballad showcases the band’s dynamic range and emotional resonance.
5 Leonard Cohen
Track 8
At a mere 1:42, “Leonard Cohen”demonstrates that brevity can indeed pack a punch. I found myself enamored by its powerful lyrics, referencing the beloved songwriter’s wisdom and evoking a deep sense of reflection, culminating in a striking finale.
4 Cool About It
Track 5
As a prime example of boygenius’ collaborative artistry, “Cool About It”features all three members as lead vocalists and was nominated for a Grammy for Best Alternative Music Performance. With balanced vocals and poignant lyrics addressing themes of romance and mental health, this track encapsulates the essence of their work.
3 Satanist
Track 9
Listen here
“Satanist”stands out as an anthem, exuding an angry, rebellious spirit that resonates deeply with fans. With its hard-hitting guitar riffs and lyrics inviting societal reflection, this track showcases the band’s fearless stance on current issues.
2 Not Strong Enough
Track 6
Listen here
The first song performed during their SNL appearance, “Not Strong Enough”exemplifies the quality that garnered the band Grammy wins for Best Rock Song and Best Rock Performance. Tackling themes of self-identity, the track’s emotionally charged chorus resonates with listeners navigating their own struggles.
1 True Blue
Track 4
Listen here
“True Blue”struck a profound chord with me at first listen. Its intricate guitar melodies paired with Lucy Dacus’ evocative vocals create a mesmerizing atmosphere. A perfect representation of boygenius’ sound, it deftly navigates emotional depths that resonate universally.
And it feels good
To be known so well
I can’t hide from you
Like I hide from myself
As a quintessential song, “True Blue”encapsulates the band’s essence while standing as a prime entry point for new listeners to explore the entirety of boygenius‘s remarkable collection, The Record.