Pierce Brosnan vs Timothy Dalton: Which James Bond Actor is Ideal for an “Older 007” Film?

The speculation surrounding a potential return of Timothy Dalton and Pierce Brosnan to the iconic role of James Bond in an upcoming installment continues to captivate audiences. As fans ponder which actor might embody an older iteration of 007 more convincingly, there is a notable backdrop of uncertainty. The unexpected delays experienced in the release of No Time To Die pale in comparison to the challenges the soon-to-be-named Bond 26 seems to be facing. The period of waiting between No Time To Die and its sequel is on track to become the longest gap between films within the James Bond franchise, and the search for a new 007 remains elusive.

Compounding the situation, producers Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson relinquished creative control of the series as of March 2025, placing the future of the franchise into the hands of Amazon MGM Studios. This shift could usher in a surprising new actor as the next 007, driving some commentators to revisit previously dismissed ideas for the franchise’s future. Given the restructuring of creative talent behind the scenes, the possibility of an older Bond project—long rumored—could finally become a reality.

Brosnan’s Return: From Playful to Grizzled 007

A Playful Approach to Bond: Brosnan’s Legacy

Both Timothy Dalton and Pierce Brosnan stand as potential candidates to reprise the role of an older James Bond, though one might suit the role better based on age and screen presence. At 79, Dalton is older than Brosnan, who is 71. Notably, both would surpass the age of the oldest actor to have portrayed Bond in the official EON series — Roger Moore was 57 during his last appearance as the iconic spy. Daniel Craig similarly captured audiences as Bond until he was 51, making the ages of the newer options intriguing.

By the conclusion of No Time To Die, it was evident the franchise was poised for transformation. With Craig’s Bond being the first to face canonical death, a new narrative could evolve wherein a previous Bond—Brosnan or Dalton—comes out of retirement to reclaim the 007 mantle. Brosnan’s interpretation was notably lighter and imbued with irony, which could lead to a compelling portrayal of an older, more seasoned agent grappling with the complexities of his legacy.

Adopting a self-referential tone would be particularly challenging in light of the serious narratives established during Craig’s tenure. While Brosnan has expressed skepticism regarding a potential older Bond in a GQ interview, his unique brand of humor positioned him well for this narrative direction.

The Case for Dalton: Embracing Comedy in an Older Bond

Transitioning to Laughter: Dalton’s Recent Career

Recalling cinematic history, there’s a compelling argument to be made for Brosnan portraying a darker, more introspective Bond, akin to Clint Eastwood’s transformative role in Unforgiven. Brosnan could explore a deeper character arc, illustrating the emotional toll of his time as 007, reflecting on the legacy of violence and the nature of heroism.

Nonetheless, Brosnan’s darker portrayal could clash with recent audience expectations, which currently lean towards lighter tones. Given that Craig’s later films received pushes for being excessively serious, the concept of a comedic, older 007 featuring Timothy Dalton could provide a refreshing contrast. Dalton’s performance in seriously dark roles contrasted with his later comedic work—seen in Hot Fuzz and the Toy Story sequels—highlights his timing and ability to adapt to humor. A quirky and humorous portrayal of a retired Bond could ultimately become a dynamic exploration of aging in the spy genre.

Why Brosnan’s Return is More Tonally Aligned

Dalton’s Return: Navigating a Shift in Tone

However, realistically incorporating Dalton’s comedic influence on the character risks tonal dissonance, contrasting sharply with the serious nature of his earlier portrayals. Dalton’s Bond films epitomized darker storytelling, largely driven by the shift towards brutally violent films like Lethal Weapon in the 1980s. Transitioning to a comedic version of 007 could lead to significant tonal inconsistency.

As modern audiences have embraced lighter narratives at the cinema, it seems Brosnan’s more playful take on 007 aligns fittingly with the franchise’s potential resurgence. While Craig’s films achieved both popularity and intrigue, they also showcased how necessary humor is for future installments to maintain relevance. Brosnan’s charm encapsulated the essence of a charming yet self-aware secret agent that contemporary viewers crave.

Recent Roles Prove Brosnan is Ready for an Older Bond

Films like Black Bag and Fast Charlie highlight Brosnan’s enduring presence within the spy genre.

By the time No Time To Die released, the landscape surrounding spy thrillers began shifting again, departing from the self-serious narratives that bewitched audiences during the Bourne era and embracing more vibrant storytelling as evidenced by the successes of the Marvel Cinematic Universe. An older, humor-infused Bond starring Brosnan is ripe for exploration, allowing the character to evolve while retaining the charm crucial to its legacy.

Though Dalton has proven his mettle in comedic roles, transitioning to this new take on Bond poses challenges given the stark contrast between his beloved reinterpretation and a more lighthearted approach. With Brosnan’s inherently playful portrayal of the character, he is ideally positioned for a successful return in the next James Bond film, outweighing the prospects of Timothy Dalton’s comeback.

Source: GQ

Source&Images