One Piece: Analyzing Why Shanks Could Be Luffy’s Final Villain

This article contains spoilers from the Elbaf arc of One Piece.

Overview

  • Shanks is a complex character, serving as a test for Luffy rather than a traditional villain.
  • His interim goal appears to be preventing Luffy from accessing the One Piece, acting as a significant hurdle in Luffy’s journey.
  • A pivotal showdown between Shanks and Luffy is anticipated to unfold on Lodestar Island, crucial to the quest for the One Piece.

For fans of One Piece, the long-anticipated reunion between Luffy and Shanks has generated immense excitement since the series’ inception. Shanks, who inspired Luffy’s dream of becoming a pirate, remains a figure of great admiration for the young captain. Alongside this admiration, Luffy made a promise to Shanks: he would return the iconic straw hat only after surpassing Shanks and his crew.

Although Luffy has attained the title of Yonko, he has yet to reach Shanks’s formidable level. With their confrontation imminent, it will likely be a decisive moment that could determine the future access to the One Piece. Given that Shanks is now pursuing the One Piece himself, he transitions into the role of an antagonist—testably presenting obstacles for Luffy that hint at a more complex rivalry.

Analyzing Shanks as a Complex Character

Shanks from One Piece
Shanks in Film Red
Luffy's Gear 5 Transformation
  • Shanks is not driven by malevolent intentions.
  • His desire is to challenge and evaluate Luffy’s growth.

Labeling Shanks as a straightforward villain in Luffy’s narrative can be misleading. His intentions towards Luffy are not malicious; rather, he symbolizes a benchmark that Luffy must surpass. Since Luffy’s victory over Kaido, Shanks has evinced his intent to pursue the One Piece, positioning himself as a formidable opponent.

As Shanks himself acknowledges: “Hey Beck, it’s time to go and claim the One Piece, don’t you think?” This statement highlights his strategic intent to thwart Luffy’s ambitions, reinforcing the notion that anyone who obstructs Luffy’s path embodies the role of a villain. Nevertheless, Shanks’s true purpose is far more nuanced; he is determined to challenge Luffy and ensure he is worthy of the title of Pirate King.

Shanks as Luffy’s Ultimate Challenge Before the Great War

Shanks as an Obstacle to Luffy’s Quest

Sad Shanks
Crying Shanks
Luffy in Gear 5

As the individual who set Luffy on the path to becoming a pirate, Shanks’s standing as the final obstacle is fitting. However, it’s important to clarify that his intent to claim the One Piece has evolved. Historically, Shanks refrained from pursuing the treasure, a choice impacted by the words of Gol D. Roger. Shanks’s journey has since taken a turn; rather than seeking the One Piece for himself, his focus shifted toward guiding the next generation.

In the past, Shanks has stated, “I’ve changed my mind. I’m not going to go for the One Piece. At least, not for now,” indicating his change in priorities following Roger’s death. The legacy of the Pirate King has evidently shaped Shanks’s current motives, steering him toward a different role in the grand narrative of piracy.

The Upcoming Showdown on Lodestar Island

Luffy Gear 5 Sun God Nika

The anticipated clash between Shanks and Luffy is poised to be a monumental spectacle within the One Piece saga. Fans can expect Shanks, currently at the peak of his powers, to pose a formidable challenge; Luffy’s strength is developing but not yet at the same height. Their confrontation is expected to unfold on Lodestar Island, a critical site in the Grand Line’s final quest.

The stakes are high, as the victor will gain access to the last Road Poneglyph, which is a key to finding the One Piece. Fans are undoubtedly rooting for Luffy to emerge victorious and continue his journey toward Laugh Tale; however, should Shanks prevail, he would hold the key to the legendary treasure and profoundly impact the future of Luffy’s ambitions.

Looking ahead, One Piece Chapter 1146 is set for release soon. Fans can anticipate the latest developments to drop on Sunday, April 20, 2025, at 12 AM JST in Japan. For those outside of Japan, the chapter will typically be available on the same date, enriching the excitement surrounding the series. Readers can enjoy the new chapter for free on Manga Plus.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog