Warning: This article contains spoilers for Daredevil: Born Again episode 7, “Art for Art’s Sake.”
The recent success of Daredevil: Born Again has been noteworthy, particularly given the tumultuous creative journey that unfolded throughout its production. Initially beset by a myriad of challenges, the show underwent a significant overhaul by the end of 2023, steering it towards a fresh narrative direction. Despite the anticipation surrounding this reboot, especially regarding the introduction of a new villain, the debut of Muse has left much to be desired.
The Resurgence of Iconic Characters: Daredevil and Kingpin
With Charlie Cox reprising his role as Matt Murdock and Vincent D’Onofrio returning as Wilson Fisk in Daredevil: Born Again, we are treated to an intriguing dynamic between these classic adversaries. Wilson Fisk’s ascent to Mayor of New York serves as a compelling backdrop for his gradual re-emergence as Kingpin, creating an opportunity for other villains to step into the spotlight. Among these is the formidable Bullseye, who returns from season 3 with deadly intentions, alongside the newly introduced artistic killer, Muse.
A New Take on Muse: Changes in the MCU Adaptation
The Mystery Behind Muse’s Identity: MCU vs. Comics
Muse made his initial appearance in Marvel Comics’ Daredevil (Vol. 5) #11, characterized by an enigmatic nature and devoid of a known civilian identity. This mystery is a key aspect of his menacing persona, making him nearly undetectable even by Daredevil’s acute senses. In stark contrast, the MCU adaptation of Muse has made a significant departure from this portrayal, opting to flesh out the character with a distinct identity as Bastian Cooper, played by Hunter Doohan. While this humanization adds depth, it also strips away much of the haunting mystery that once defined the character’s allure.
My Disappointment in Muse’s Background Reveal
From Enigmatic to Mundane: The Case of Muse’s Identity
While I appreciated the chilling sequences featuring Muse donning his mask and committing horrific acts in the name of his art, including forcing blood from victims to create murals, the segments where he appeared unmasked left much to be desired. The exploration of his character in the seventh episode, titled “Art for Art’s Sake,”presented him in a therapy session with Dr. Heather Glenn, revealing a rather generic backstory of parental pressure and childhood taekwondo lessons. This narrative felt lackluster and failed to capture the essence of what made Muse a captivating villain in the comics.
Season 2: A Chance for Muse to Evolve
Speculations Surrounding Muse’s Possible Comeback
Currently in production, Daredevil: Born Again season 2 promises to escalate the stakes as Charlie Cox returns in a striking black Daredevil costume adorned with the classic “DD”emblem. Given the darker, more mystical elements that have permeated recent Marvel narratives, there is potential for Muse to be reintroduced in a more formidable manner. In the comics, Muse meets his end but subsequently interacts with a forsaken soul, offering intriguing narrative threads that could translate well to the screen. Alternatively, a storyline involving copycats could revive the chilling essence of Muse’s character, potentially allowing Bastian Cooper to emerge as a sinister homage to the original, enigmatic Muse.