Moana’s Demigod Evolution Highlights the Flaws in Disney’s Initial Moana 2 Concept

The format of Moana 2 in its early stages would not have sustained its success over time, particularly with the sequel’s innovative demigod twist. The film has emerged as a massive triumph for Disney, amassing over $1 billion in global box office sales, validating the decision to debut it in theaters. The conclusion of Moana 2 opens the door to further storytelling opportunities, where themes such as a larger confrontation with Nalo, alliances between different islands, and deeper character explorations for Matangi and Simea come to the forefront, positioning the franchise for a vibrant and dynamic future.

Audience enthusiasm for both Moana and Maui has shown a renewed vigor, indicating a sustained interest in expanding the narrative universe. Particularly, Moana’s evolution into a demigod carries significant implications for the anticipated Moana 3, suggesting that the series is on the brink of a transformative emotional journey. Despite this promising direction, it’s worth noting that Disney faced challenges with the project’s original development, which almost squandered the franchise’s potential through a less effective release strategy.

Moana’s Demigod Transformation Was Initially Intended for Disney+

Series Finale Would Have Set the Stage for a Theatrical Sequel

Images of Moana in Moana 2
Custom Image by Ana Nieves

Originally, 2023 was slated to be the year that would showcase Moana’s adventures through a TV series; however, Disney pivoted to reimagine it as a feature film. In an interview with Screen Rant, co-directors Jason Hand, Dana Ledoux Miller, and David Derrick Jr. shared insights on this transition. They noted that the adaptation required simplifying secondary character arcs to prioritize Moana’s character development, allowing the animation quality to shine on the larger screen.

One of the critical issues surrounding Moana 2 was its episodic feel. The creators’ focus on Moana’s growth as a leader suggested that an impactful moment—her sacrifice to unite her island with other ocean peoples—was intended for the series. The structure of the film and the way it cultivates its themes imply that the final episode of the Disney+ series would have culminated in Moana’s transformation into a demigod, potentially paving the way for a future theatrical sequel.

Moana’s Transition to Demigod on Disney+ Could Have Alienated Viewers

Limited Audience Reach on Disney+ Would Have Hindered Moana’s Progression

Moana as a demigod in Moana 2
Walt Disney Studios Motion Pictures

The decision to shift Moana 2 from streaming to theatrical release paid off significantly, with the sequel nearly doubling the original’s box office earnings. Remaining as a series would have likely limited Disney’s revenue potential and stunted the franchise’s ability to expand. As a result, fewer viewers would have engaged with Moana: The Series, meaning key developments like Moana’s demigod transformation and the introduction of important characters, such as Simea and Matangi, could have gone unnoticed, reducing their relevance in the overarching narrative.

Movie

Box Office (Via The Numbers)

Moana

$684,654,985

Moana 2

$1,059,544,057

Furthermore, a significant number of fans may never have learned about Moana’s transformation had it been relegated to a series. This would have posed a challenge for subsequent theatrical releases, as many audience members would struggle to reconcile the original film’s conclusion with Moana’s sudden evolution into a demigod. Such an abrupt transition could risk fragmenting the narrative’s flow, undermining the story’s cohesion and the franchise’s overall integrity.

Disney Preserved Moana’s Legacy by Continuing Her Journey in Theaters

Moana 2 Solidified the Franchise as One of Disney’s Premier Offerings

None
None
None
None
None
None
None

After its successful theatrical release, the franchise’s directors confirmed that theatrical storytelling was essential for Moana’s ongoing journey, echoing Derrick Jr.’s assertion that the series “begs for the big screen.”They made it a priority to ensure that fans, both new and returning, had the opportunity to experience the evolution of Moana’s story with her transition into adulthood. Whether watched in cinemas or later streamed, a blockbuster movie garners more visibility than a series that might be overshadowed by other leading television shows.

The Moana franchise now stands poised for enduring success, as the groundwork laid by Moana 2 promises an exciting future. Fans can anticipate even richer storytelling in Moana 3, which aims to push the narrative boundaries established in the sequel while further exploring Moana’s demigod powers. Moreover, the upcoming live-action adaptation could provide a fresh perspective on the material, presenting an opportunity to address any shortcomings of Moana 2. In any approach, the potential for Moana to reign over the cinematic landscape remains robust and encouraging.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog