Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2 immerses players in a vivid narrative of conflict and turmoil, as two monarchs engage in fierce warfare. You step into the shoes of Henry, a former blacksmith’s son, now transformed into a noble page and steadfast guardian. Upon reaching Kuttenberg, players find themselves ensnared in the escalating strife between rival factions.
Among the key characters intertwined in this saga is Matthew the Collector, an NPC central to the pivotal mission titled The Devil’s Pack. As players navigate this storyline, they will confront a critical choice regarding Matthew’s fate. This guide outlines Matthew’s role, the implications of your choices, and essential information to navigate this dilemma with clarity.
Should You Eliminate Matthew the Collector in Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2?

In this segment of the game, Henry teams up with a band of misfits to enlist more fighters for their cause, particularly focusing on the allies of the infamous Dry Devils. During The Devil’s Pack quest, Henry is tasked with locating these individuals.
One such individual is Matthew the Collector. Players may encounter him on the roads of Kuttenberg, where he has made a name for himself with a new gang by imposing extortionate “taxes”on unsuspecting travelers. Fortunately for Henry, Matthew is frequently found on the route eastward from Suchdol.
Moreover, players have the opportunity to confront Matthew during fast travel encounters. Engaging him reveals that he has no interest in rejoining his former group and instead obstinately attempts to collect 1000 Groschen from Henry. Players have several options when responding, including:
- MEDIUM: “The Devil will have his revenge?”(Speech)
- HARD: “I’m not giving you anything!”(Intimidation)

If players dismiss Matthew or fail the persuasion checks, he and his companions will attack. This creates a scenario where players may have to either eliminate Matthew or incapacitate him, although the latter may prove challenging given his aggression and the presence of around five other hostile characters. Interestingly, there are no repercussions for opting to kill Matthew, and players will still achieve their objectives despite his demise. Upon returning to the Dry Devil, players will find that he remains unfazed by the outcome.
Strategies for Facing Matthew the Collector in KCD2
Engaging Matthew the Collector and his gang can be challenging, making strategic preparation crucial. Here are several recommendations for a successful confrontation:
- Bring Mutt Along: The loyal dog, Mutt, can serve as a valuable ally, distracting opponents and aiding in combat.
- Repair Gear: Ensure that weapons and armor are in top condition before the encounter. Well-maintained equipment can significantly affect the outcome of the fight.
- Stay Mobile: Keep Henry’s horse nearby for a quick escape if the situation deteriorates, particularly when outnumbered.
- Utilize the Environment: Try to maneuver enemies into confined spaces or fight near obstacles to gain a tactical advantage and regroup when needed.
Ultimately, whether players decide to kill Matthew the Collector or let him go is inconsequential for progress, as long as they engage him. Should they choose to eliminate him, they can loot him for the Rare Book located in Sedletz.