Warning! SPOILERS for 1923 Season 2, Episode 6, “The Mountain Teeth Of Monsters”
The ongoing conflict affecting the Dutton family has intensified, particularly evident in the tragic death of Jack Dutton (portrayed by Darren Mann) in season 2, episode 6 of 1923. This pivotal moment challenges a well-liked fan theory regarding Alex (played by Julia Schlaepfer) and Spencer Dutton (Brandon Sklenar). As the latest season unfolds, Taylor Sheridan’s gripping prequel to Yellowstone presents formidable obstacles for Jacob (Harrison Ford) and Cara Dutton (Helen Mirren). Jack and his fiancée, Elizabeth Strafford (Michelle Randolph), have been pivotal in supporting the family at their ranch, but the recent events in “The Mountain Teeth of Monsters” thrust Jack into a perilous situation.
Meanwhile, Spencer Dutton journeys back to Montana, eager to reunite with Elizabeth, while his wife, Alexandra of Sussex, faces significant challenges in her attempts to deliver crucial news to him about their unborn child. Following the events of the first season finale of 1923, many fans speculated that Alex was expecting. Concurrently, Elizabeth’s own hopes of motherhood appeared dim after her heartbreaking loss. These circumstances fueled a fan theory with considerable traction, but the recent episode has cast doubt on its validity.
Dissecting the Fan Theory Surrounding Alexandra Dutton & Elizabeth Strafford
The Belief That Elizabeth Might Raise Alexandra’s Child
Following hints of Alexandra’s pregnancy and Elizabeth’s poignant loss, a theory gained momentum among fans regarding the intriguing dynamics between the Duttons. It was widely speculated that Alex would successfully give birth to her child but meet a tragic end before being able to raise the infant. Consequently, many anticipated that Elizabeth would step in to care for her sister-in-law’s child. As 1923 season 2 began, this theory seemed plausible, especially when Alex confided in her friend Jennifer (Jo Ellen Pellman) about her pregnancy. Throughout her challenging journey back to the ranch, fans feared that Alex’s pursuit could end in tragedy.
However, significant plot developments in season 2, episode 4 altered this trajectory. After enduring a traumatic encounter with a rabid wolf, Elizabeth discovers she is pregnant once more. Yet, tensions remain high for both couples as they face their respective destinies. Following Jack’s untimely demise, the future for Elizabeth becomes increasingly precarious. Additionally, it’s unclear if she will choose to remain at the ranch after the conflict concludes, as she previously expressed a strong desire to return to Boston.
How Episode 6 Alters The Narrative of Alex & Elizabeth’s Relationship
The Shift: Alex May Now Raise Elizabeth’s Child
With Jack’s death now a pivotal plot point, Elizabeth’s potential departure from the Yellowstone Dutton ranch appears increasingly likely. This shifts the narrative, positioning Alex as a more probable guardian for Spencer’s nephew rather than Elizabeth. As Spencer races home in 1923 season 2, episode 6, there are strong indications that his character will survive the unfolding turmoil. If Alex successfully returns, the couple could assume control of the family legacy tied to the Yellowstone Ranch, opening their home to a new generation.
There is also the potential for Elizabeth to return to Boston, paving the way for future developments where her son might be sent back to Yellowstone to explore his family’s heritage. The speculation surrounding this narrative twist reflects the show’s broader themes of adoptive families, much like Jacob and Cara Dutton’s commitment to raising John and Spencer as their own. This notion of familial love despite biological ties has been a cornerstone of the Dutton family’s saga. Ultimately, if Elizabeth does return to Boston, her son could someday reclaim his roots at Yellowstone, creating a compelling conclusion that honors both fan theories and the series’ narrative style.