In the aftermath of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel‘s series finale two years ago, showrunner Amy Sherman-Palladino remains uncertain if it was truly the right moment to conclude the story. The show debuted in 2017 and swiftly emerged as one of Prime Video’s standout original series. Centered on Midge Maisel (played by Rachel Brosnahan), a housewife stepping into the world of stand-up comedy in the 1950s, the series was crafted by Sherman-Palladino in collaboration with her husband, Dan Palladino. Throughout its five-season journey, the show received numerous Emmy Awards, covering categories from acting to costuming, ultimately wrapping up in 2023 with a finale that fast-forwarded through significant milestones in Midge’s personal and professional life.
In a recent interview with Variety to promote their latest Prime Video project, Étoile, the creators reflected on the conclusion of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel. Although Dan Palladino was hesitant to delve into the topic, Sherman-Palladino openly shared her mixed emotions about the series ending. Here’s an excerpt from her poignant response:
You can’t ever say it’s the best thing when you have something very special. Look, this business is this business. There are just things you can’t control.
Implications for The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel’s Legacy
A Unique Series With Untapped Potential
The fifth season of The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel raced through pivotal moments in Midge’s journey—from her breakthrough on The Gordon Ford Show to a time-skipping finale that showcased her enduring success over decades. Although these significant events were powerful, they also suggested that a more gradual, detailed depiction of Midge’s growth was initially envisioned. Sherman-Palladino’s reflections illustrate how even a critically acclaimed, award-winning series can be impacted by changes in streaming strategy and industry decisions, no matter its achievements.
Despite offering meaningful closure to many character arcs, especially Midge’s, the series finale featured an emotionally resonant farewell between Midge and Susie, encapsulating their friendship beautifully. Given Sherman-Palladino’s reputation for crafting intricate worlds and long-term character development—like in Gilmore Girls—her sentiments about the series ending resonate deeply. While a five-season run is commendable in an era where many premium comedies struggle to exceed three seasons, it also underscores that, at times, quality alone is insufficient to prolong a series.
Reflections on Sherman-Palladino’s Bittersweet Farewell
The End of the Series, But Its Legacy Endures
Sherman-Palladino’s candidness reinforces a sentiment shared by many fans: there are still stories yet to be told in this vibrant world. Her transparency is both refreshing and revealing, showcasing the profound affection she has for the universe she built. The striking visuals and clever writing rendered The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel a genuine labor of love, establishing a connection with its audience. Although there are currently no plans for a revival or spinoff, Sherman-Palladino’s insights provide a glimmer of hope that further narratives within The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel universe may materialize in the future.
Source: Variety