Is the Buffy the Vampire Slayer Reboot Capable of Resurrecting This Beloved Character (And Should It?)

Reviving Buffy the Vampire Slayer: Exciting News for Fans

  • Sarah Michelle Gellar set to reprise her iconic role, generating significant buzz among the show’s fanbase.
  • Original characters Cordelia Chase and Dawn Summers expected to return, adding nostalgia to the new series.
  • Speculations arise about Anya Jenkins’ potential comeback, igniting discussions over her fitting involvement given her past.

The revival of Buffy the Vampire Slayer has sparked excitement, especially with the confirmation of Sarah Michelle Gellar returning as Buffy Summers. Since Gellar hinted at the possibility of her return back in December 2024, fans have been eagerly anticipating what this could mean for their beloved character. The recent announcement in February 2025 regarding Hulu’s potential pilot order has only intensified this excitement. Imagining Buffy’s life today stirs a sense of curiosity—what has changed? Is she still battling vampires, or has she moved on to a new chapter?

The revival also opens the door for numerous original characters to return, creating possibilities for both regular and cameo appearances. Fans are particularly hopeful to see Cordelia Chase (played by Charisma Carpenter) again, alongside a respectful tribute to Dawn Summers (portrayed by Michelle Trachtenberg). There’s also ongoing chatter about the possibility of Anya Jenkins (played by Emma Caulfield) returning, though her reappearance raises compelling questions.

Exploring Anya Jenkins’ Possible Return in the Reboot

Buffy the Vampire Slayer Anya looking pensive

Conversations about Anya’s potential comeback have ignited lively debates on platforms like Reddit. Suggestions vary, with one user proposing a flashback scene where D’Hoffryn revives Anya just before the collapse of the Hellmouth. Another user pointed out that given the supernatural theme of the series, “there is always a way” to bring her back.

However, Anya’s death during an intense battle in season seven remains a poignant point of contention. Many fans argue that her sacrificial end should not be forgotten. One noted, “She died heroically fighting to save the humans she’d learned to become,”while another added, “I would be against reviving dead characters.” This sentiment reflects the deep emotional ties viewers have developed with Anya’s character.

Despite the complexities surrounding Anya’s death, nostalgic sentiments for original characters in the series make a case for her return compelling. Two possible routes emerge: either Buffy reveals that Anya miraculously survived or that magic brings her back. Addressing Anya’s resurrection should ideally carry an emotional weight akin to Buffy’s mother’s death in season 5’s “The Body”, which left a significant impact on fans. Anya’s reappearance could provide closure and fulfillment for those who wish to see her journey continue.

In light of the series’ climactic and poignant finale, simply reversing Anya’s fate may disrupt the storyline’s integrity. Instead, a creative approach could see the characters using magic to resurrect Anya. Additionally, introducing a twist where Anya returns as a demon could lead to intriguing dynamics and generate both tension and humor between her and Buffy. This scenario could resonate with long-term fans and reflect the ongoing battles Buffy faces, even years after saving Sunnydale. The potential for comedic moments regarding Buffy’s past encounters with Anya in demon form could also enrich the narrative.

The Arc of Anya Jenkins in Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Anya in Buffy the Vampire Slayer

Anya Jenkins was first introduced in season 3, episode 9, titled “The Wish.”By the end of that season, her presence became integral to the series. Initially appearing as a demon granting Cordelia Chase’s wishes, a twist occurs when Giles saves the day by transforming Anya back into a human, creating layers to her character development.

Ultimately, Anya’s journey comes to a tragic end in season 7, episode 22, “Chosen,” when a Bringer attacks and kills her. Anya’s complexity stems from her evolution from an evil demon to a chaotic yet treasured member of the group. Her relationship with Xander Harris (portrayed by Nicholas Brendon) further solidified her popularity, making viewers invested in her story arc.

As fans discuss the viability of Anya’s return in the revival, many wonder how her character could fit into the narrative without Xander’s presence. Nevertheless, Anya’s multifaceted history—having experienced both good and evil—presents exciting opportunities for narration. Her transition back into the series could offer fresh perspectives and much-needed nostalgia for long-standing followers of Buffy the Vampire Slayer.

Source&Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog