The launch of Doom: The Dark Ages has introduced players on PC to seamless controller support. Users can harness the power of an Xbox controller, which enhances gameplay with features like haptic feedback and vibrations. Nevertheless, as this title is a first-person shooter, playing with a keyboard and mouse also offers distinct benefits. Additionally, Bethesda’s latest update has reinstated modding capabilities, giving gamers compelling reasons to consider sticking with traditional input methods.
This raises an essential question: Which setup is optimal for Doom: The Dark Ages enthusiasts? After extensive testing, we provide an in-depth comparison to uncover the strengths and weaknesses of both controllers and keyboard and mouse configurations. Join us as we explore the nuances of each input device to determine the best choice for gameplay.
Comparing Input Methods: Controllers vs. Keyboard and Mouse in Doom: The Dark Ages

Before diving deeper into the analysis, it’s crucial to acknowledge that the selection of gaming peripherals is highly personal. Individual comfort and familiarity play significant roles in determining preference. That subjectivity also applies to this comparison, ensuring it reflects a mix of experience and personal bias.
Doom: The Dark Ages presents a learning curve that echoes the original Doom experience, marking a welcome departure from its recent predecessors. While past experiences with the franchise may inform your setup preference, it’s advisable to keep an open mind during this analysis.
User Interface and Menu Navigation
The game design of Doom: The Dark Ages emphasizes core gameplay rather than elaborate UI menus, making navigation straightforward. However, controllers often struggle with longer menus due to their layout and navigation structure. Even though players won’t encounter extensive text menus, keyboard and mouse setups typically provide greater efficiency in navigation.
- Keyboard and Mouse ➡️⬅️ (0.5)
- Controller ➡️⬅️ (0.5)
Gameplay Elements: Hotkeys and Customization
When it comes to hotkeys and customization, keyboard and mouse configurations excel. With the ability to assign numerous macros and shortcuts, users can enjoy unparalleled freedom in their gameplay experience. While a controller does provide several buttons, entry-level options like the standard Xbox controller may lack the extra triggers and shoulder buttons necessary for extensive customization.
- Keyboard and Mouse ✅ (1.5)
- Controller ❌ (0.5)
Gameplay Dynamics: Combat, Movement, and Camera Control
In Doom: The Dark Ages, precise combat and quick movements are crucial to navigating its fast-paced environment. Keyboard and mouse setups are designed to facilitate these demands, offering rapid adjustments and pinpoint accuracy. While controllers provide smooth movement through their analog joysticks, they may hinder performance when faced with diverse enemy spawn points and immediate combat scenarios.
- Keyboard and Mouse ✅ (2.5)
- Controller ❌ (0.5)
Comfort and Immersion

For casual gamers, comfort and immersion might be the deciding factors in input device selection. This aspect often varies based on individual preferences. Keyboard and mouse setups can enhance focus during intense gaming sessions, contributing to overall performance as they generally decrease in-game deaths.
Alternatively, controllers offer their own unique advantages, including better couch compatibility, enhanced immersion through haptic feedback, and ease of use. When compared to keyboards and mice, the controller allows for a more relaxed gaming experience.
- Keyboard and Mouse ➡️⬅️ (3)
- Controller ➡️⬅️ (1)
Modding Capabilities
With the recent introduction of modding support in Doom: The Dark Ages, keyboard and mouse setups again prove advantageous. Their multitude of buttons allows for swift access to script mods and custom shortcuts, something that is significantly restricted when using a controller with its limited button configuration.
- Keyboard and Mouse ✅ (4)
- Controller ❌ (1)
Conclusion: Controller versus Keyboard and Mouse in Doom: The Dark Ages

Ultimately, the decision between using a controller or keyboard and mouse hinges on personal preference. However, in the context of Doom: The Dark Ages, a clear advantage emerges for keyboard and mouse users. This combination offers extensive modding options, superior gameplay customization, and enhanced precision—elements essential for mastering this dynamic hack-and-slash shooter hybrid.