The Pokémon anime excels at presenting Ash Ketchum as an everyman, enabling children to see themselves in his character as he embarks on various adventures. However, a recurring theme in the movies seems to upend his status as an ordinary kid, transforming him instead into a legendary hero. This raises the question: why does this shift occur, especially when the same creators are behind both the anime and the film series?
Ash Ketchum, while a beloved character, lacks many extraordinary attributes in the main series. He isn’t particularly intelligent or athletic, often displaying a form of bravery that can border on recklessness. Designed as a relatable figure for young viewers, he represents the journey of discovery that resonates with childhood experiences. His triumphs inspire audiences, yet the films frequently paint him in a different light altogether.
Pokémon Wants Ash to Be a Hero
Ash is Given Special Roles in Several Movies
The transformation of Ash into a pivotal character began with Pokémon the Movie 2000. In this installment, he is depicted as a “chosen one,”prophesied to restore balance among the legendary avian Pokémon. This narrative thrusts him into the role of a savior, where he undertakes herculean tasks to bring harmony back to the world, fostering a notable bond with Lugia.
By the eighth movie, Lucario and the Mystery of Mew, Ash’s character receives another boost when he is suggested to be a reincarnation of the famed Aura Guardian, Sir Aaron. Asserting his unique connection to Aura—a rare power among humans—Ash’s abilities play a crucial role in his journey, impacting key moments in the series, including his bond with Greninja.
While these examples highlight the shift in Ash’s portrayal, other films such as Pokémon: Mewtwo Strikes Back provide similar treatment, showcasing Ash as an exceptional trainer. Films like Hoopa and the Clash of Ages also position him in a heroic light, where he must confront a dark legacy. The recent reboot starting with I Choose You! emphasizes his selection by Ho-Oh, redirecting his path distinctly from the classic tales celebrated by fans.
Why Change Ash to Be a Chosen One?
The Movies Had Bigger, More Epic Plots That Demand a Special Protagonist
Ash’s evolution from a simple kid to a chosen hero is a gradual process that doesn’t apply universally across all films. Certain narratives, like Pokémon the Movie 2000, require a compelling reason for Ash’s deep involvement, leading to the creative decision to embed him within a prophecy. The story’s impact hinges upon the community’s belief that only Ash can resolve its challenges.
In Lucario and the Mystery of Mew, the stakes are heightened due to Lucario’s past distrust of humans, exacerbated by its connection to Sir Aaron. Ash’s resemblance to this hero complicates Lucario’s emotional arc, thereby creating a layered conflict. Without Ash’s unique Aura abilities, the narrative would struggle to maintain its tension and resolve, emphasizing his importance to the overall plot.
Furthermore, the premise of the reboot centers around Ash being identified by Ho-Oh, pitting him against the legendary Pokémon in a climactic encounter that leaves much to viewers’ imagination. This emphasis on Ash’s chosen status may have sparked mixed opinions, as it alters his identity from an endearing, relatable youth to a legendary figure embarking on a fantastical crusade.
Can Pokémon Have Epic Plots Without Making Ash Special?
Plenty of Other Pokémon Movies Have Proven It’s Possible
While the trend of portraying Ash as a special character prevails in the films, there are notable exceptions where he remains a conventional protagonist. For instance, in the third film, Spell of the Unown, Ash’s involvement is motivated by his mother’s connection to the plot rather than any extraordinary powers or predestination.
The Sinnoh series films, including Rise of Darkrai and Arceus and the Jewel of Life, also weave engaging tales around legendary Pokémon where Ash’s role is primarily that of a fortunate helper rather than a chosen hero. These movies are frequently lauded as some of the franchise’s finest, successfully crafting compelling narratives without necessitating a change in Ash’s character.
This remarkable balance suggests that engaging stories can indeed be told without elevating Ash to a legendary status. With an expansive series featuring Ash Ketchum, the introduction of unique backgrounds or chosen narratives can feel forced. Ultimately, the personality and relatability of Ash as an everyman resonate more profoundly with audiences than the repetitive heroic tropes seen in many adaptations.
Fans widely appreciate Ash as he is—there’s no pressing need for him to transition into a more distinguished role for cinematic success. While the intentions behind these narrative choices are understandable, the essence of Pokémon thrives when Ash Ketchum remains the relatable hero rather than an exalted figure defined by prophecy.