Throughout the course of three seasons, Sheriff Gordo Sena has established himself as a surprisingly pivotal character in Dark Winds Season 3. A professional portrayal by A Martinez has breathed life into the role, making Gordo a standout amidst a sea of characters. As the storyline progresses, it seems increasingly uncertain whether he will return for a potential Season 4, which is disheartening for fans. This season has unfolded the most intricate case so far, intertwining the narratives of Joe Leaphorn and Chee with that of Bernadette, alongside introducing new characters that have significantly influenced the plot.
Although the new faces have contributed to the unfolding drama, it’s the beloved characters from previous seasons who remain the backbone of the story. Sheriff Gordo, in particular, has received expanded attention this season, enhancing his role within the narrative. Martinez’s portrayal of Gordo has effectively added layers to the character, allowing him to serve as a crucial counterbalance to Joe Leaphorn’s often tumultuous journey, especially since the arrival of Agent Sylvia Washington on the reservation.
Sheriff Gordo: The Season’s Unsung Hero
A Levelheaded, Loyal Companion

This season has truly seen Gordo emerge as the Most Valuable Player. While he played a significant role in Season 2, his character development had been somewhat limited. Season 3 marks a turning point for Gordo as he becomes a stabilizing force for Joe, who has been visibly struggling since the investigation into B.J. Vines’ murder began. Gordo’s calm demeanor helps to ground Joe, gently nudging him to remain composed amidst the chaos.
Furthermore, Gordo embodies the essence of a true friend, exemplified when he assists Joe with a literal cover-up, illustrating his unwavering loyalty. The subtle clues from Season 2 suggested Gordo may have been aware of Joe’s involvement in Vines’ fate, and Season 3 confirms his knowledge without passing judgement. Instead, he actively works to prevent Joe from making choices that would lead to self-incrimination, showcasing the depth of their friendship.
Gordo’s Retirement: A Looming Decision
Disillusioned with His Role

Despite his emerging prominence in Season 3, the future of Sheriff Gordo in the upcoming season remains uncertain. As alluded to in previous conversations, Gordo has expressed his intentions to retire, a decision that was reiterated in the first episode of this season. The light-hearted banter between him and Joe hinted at the possibility of his phased exit from law enforcement, leaving fans wondering about his long-term role in the series.
Moreover, Gordo’s retirement seems to be more pressing with each unfolding event. Joe’s dire choices surrounding B.J. Vines, coupled with the mounting pressures of law enforcement scrutiny, not only jeopardize Joe’s future but also Gordo’s reputation and peace. Although Gordo adheres to the unspoken rule of plausible deniability, the risks involved could reinforce his intentions to step away from a career that has become increasingly troubling for him.
Expanding Gordo’s Role Beyond the Source Material
Adapting Hillerman’s Vision

A testament to A Martinez’s impactful performance, Sheriff Gordo’s character has evolved beyond his minor role in Tony Hillerman’s original novels. In Hillerman’s works, he is primarily featured in People of Darkness, where his character is substantially less developed than in the TV adaptation. Unlike the books, where Gordo hails from Valencia County, Arizona, the series reimagines him with a more nuanced backstory, including elements of tragedy and loss that resonate more deeply within the narrative’s framework.
This creative maneuvering presents a fresh take on Gordo’s character, intertwining his narrative with Jo’s, offering a unique layering of their backgrounds and experiences. A Martinez’s compelling portrayal might have prompted writers to rethink Gordo’s significance, highlighting the necessity of his return for future episodes.
A Case for Gordo’s Return in Season 4
Possibly as a Consultant
While the chances of Gordo’s return in Season 4 may seem slim, there’s still hope. The creative team behind Dark Winds possesses flexibility and ingenuity, so if they can find a meaningful role for A Martinez, it should be explored. Gordo could transition into a consultant’s position for Joe, providing invaluable insights gained from his career, or shift into a more civilian role as Joe’s confidant outside law enforcement.
Maintaining Gordo’s presence in the narrative would enhance the show’s dynamics significantly, fostering a unique rapport that Joe lacks with other characters. Losing that connection would be a detriment to the series’ overall richness. Without Sheriff Gordo, Dark Winds risks becoming a less engaging experience for its audience.