Hayley Atwell, known for her portrayal of Captain Carter in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU), recently shared her thoughts on her brief cameo in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Despite her enthusiasm for the role, Atwell expressed disappointment over how her character was handled in the film. First introduced as Peggy Carter in 2011’s Captain America: The First Avenger, she quickly became a fan favorite, leading to her own series, Agent Carter, which aired for two seasons.
Atwell’s character has also appeared in several pivotal MCU films, including Captain America: The Winter Soldier and Avengers: Endgame. Most recently, she voiced an alternate version of her character in the animated series What If…?, where Peggy becomes a super-soldier. This led to her portrayal of Captain Carter in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness, where she was a member of the Illuminati. However, her on-screen time was notably brief, culminating in a dramatic death at the hands of Scarlet Witch, played by Elizabeth Olsen.
During her guest appearance on Reign with Josh Smith, Atwell candidly discussed her frustrations surrounding this portrayal. She reflected on the filming experience, emphasizing her desire to advocate for herself with “grace.”Atwell felt that her character’s powerful line, “I could do this all day,”was undermined by her sudden demise, stating, “she’s so undermined.”This was particularly disheartening for someone who has invested so much into the character.
“I remember looking at the frame and noting that the lighting was quite harsh. I approached someone high up and suggested, ‘Can I offer a possibility that I actually come in from that side?’ I love collaborating on technical aspects, but I was met with a dismissive joke. They said, ‘Oh, sure, Hayley, I’ll just tell our Oscar-winning editor that you have some choices you’d like to make.’ I thought, ‘Considering he’s an Oscar-winning editor, he’ll appreciate a good idea.'”
“I told him, ‘You can’t bully me; I’ve got a jetpack on.'”
Even though Atwell felt disappointed with the end result, she emphasized the importance of asserting herself creatively and respectfully in a collaborative environment. She noted that this experience provided her with the opportunity to express her ideas more confidently moving forward.
Interpreting Hayley Atwell’s Comments on Doctor Strange

Although Captain Carter’s cameo was fleeting, it served more than just an introduction to the Illuminati; it illustrated the desperate lengths Scarlet Witch would go to reunite with her children. Atwell’s reference to the iconic Captain America line makes her character’s abrupt exit even more anticlimactic. Additionally, her reflections on the lighting during filming mirror Captain Carter’s own resilience and strength, adding depth to the narrative beyond the screen.
Our Perspective on Hayley Atwell’s Insights

According to Atwell, Captain Carter did not receive the action sequence she merited in Doctor Strange in the Multiverse of Madness. Nevertheless, her character shines brightly in other MCU entries, particularly in What If…?, where she takes on leadership roles, including that of the Guardians of the Multiverse. Furthermore, there are ongoing rumors regarding her potential appearances in future MCU projects, such as Avengers: Doomsday. Thus, while one lackluster moment may be disappointing, it does not diminish her significance within the broader storytelling landscape of the Marvel universe.