Harry Potter Foreshadowed Major Snape Twist in Deathly Hallows Nine Years Prior

Among the myriad characters in the Harry Potter series, Severus Snape stands out with a particularly compelling narrative arc. His redemption in Deathly Hallows was subtly foreshadowed long before the series reached its climax. Initially introduced as the enigmatic Potions Master at Hogwarts, Snape is instantly recognizable, marked by his greasy black hair and dark demeanor. His apparent disdain for Harry and cruel treatment of students create an early impression of him as a villain. However, as the story unfolds, particularly in Goblet of Fire, Snape’s character becomes increasingly complex and dangerous, ultimately leading to unexpected revelations about his true nature.

In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows, Harry learns that Snape has been playing a dual role as a double agent throughout the series. While he outwardly aligned himself with Voldemort’s forces, his loyalty actually lay with Dumbledore and the Order of the Phoenix. This alignment was deeply rooted in Snape’s enduring love for Lily Potter. His affection for her compelled him to protect Harry over the years. This astonishing revelation catches both Harry and readers by surprise, though the groundwork for this twist is laid as early as the first book in the series.

The Foreshadowing of Snape’s Trustworthiness in Sorcerer’s Stone

Masterful Deception: Snape’s Skillful Cover

Snape Teaching a Class
Snape's First Encounter with Harry
Snape at a Quidditch Match

Long before Snape’s true intentions were clarified in Deathly Hallows, hints of his nobility emerged in Sorcerer’s Stone. Throughout this initial installment, Harry, Ron, and Hermione suspect Snape of plotting malevolence revolving around the iconic Sorcerer’s Stone. Yet, the reality is that Snape not only remains innocent but actively works to thwart Quirrell’s schemes, subtly positioning him as a character worthy of trust.

However, neither Harry nor the readers initially grasp the significance of this moment. Soon after Sorcerer’s Stone, Snape’s cruel behavior resurfaces, including his ongoing bullying of students. By the time of Order of the Phoenix, his apparent allegiance to Voldemort appears solidified. He even claims that his efforts against Quirrell stemmed from ignorance of Voldemort’s involvement. This careful construction of his character allows readers to remain convinced of his villainy for much of the series.

The Complexity of Snape’s Character

Snape: An Antihero with Flaws

Snape in Deathly Hallows Part 2

Snape’s intricacies position him more as an antihero rather than a traditional hero. Despite having Harry’s welfare at heart, his harsh treatment of students complicates any righteous claims. His allegiance is not to Harry as a person but rather to Lily, who consistently rebuffed his affections. Moreover, Harry, not Snape, is the true catalyst for stopping Quirrell from procuring the Sorcerer’s Stone. Thus, while Snape’s redemptive arc is significant, it is also imperfect and gives rise to debate among fans.

Hermione’s Insight into Bias

Draco’s Missed Opportunities for Redemption

Draco Malfoy
Quidditch Match
Snape and McGonagall
Emma Watson as Hermione Granger
Untitled Image

Hermione Granger serves as a voice of reason, frequently reminding Harry (and the audience) of his biases toward characters like Snape and Draco. Despite Snape’s gruff exterior, Hermione points out Dumbledore’s trust in him as a significant endorsement. In numerous instances, Hermione advocates for a more nuanced understanding of Snape’s motives, which Harry struggles to adopt.

Draco Malfoy also exemplifies the potential for redemption, yet his actions are often overshadowed by his upbringing and age. By the end of Deathly Hallows, Draco’s hesitance to even acknowledge Harry during a pivotal moment indicates his capacity for change. Many fans believe that Draco’s character deserved more exploration into his potential for redemption, akin to Snape’s arc.

The Resonance of Snape’s Story in Deathly Hallows

Snape’s Legacy: A Complicated Figure

The Death of Severus Snape

Ultimately, Sorcerer’s Stone adeptly plays a pivotal role in revealing the complexities of Snape’s character long before the climactic moments of Deathly Hallows. This subtle storytelling invites readers to reassess characters through a different lens over time, enriching the overall narrative experience. It will be intriguing to observe how HBO’s upcoming adaptation of Harry Potter reinterprets Snape’s multifaceted nature. Depending on their approach, we might see either a character deeply flawed or one that offers a touch more sympathy.

Snape remains one of the most intricate characters in the Harry Potter series. Existing in a gray area between good and evil, he evokes strong opinions among readers—some admire his depth while others find him unlikable. Nevertheless, it is indisputable that he is granted a uniquely compelling story throughout the Harry Potter novels.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog