The casting of Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman in the DC Extended Universe (DCEU) marked a significant moment, celebrated by fans and critics alike. However, an intriguing alternative casting choice emerged during discussions: Jaimie Alexander, widely recognized for her portrayal of Lady Sif in the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU). This tantalizing “what if”scenario keeps the conversation alive among enthusiasts, pondering how Alexander might have brought her unique talents to the Amazonian warrior.
Wonder Woman, portrayed by Gal Gadot, first graced the big screen in the 2016 blockbuster Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice. Her character quickly became a vital part of the DCEU, leading to a solo film directed by Patty Jenkins in 2017. The movie was lauded for its inspirational tone and Gadot’s captivating performance, solidifying Wonder Woman’s position as a cinematic icon. The character has since appeared in pivotal crossover films like Justice League and a sequel, Wonder Woman 1984, contributing significantly to the DCEU’s narrative arc.
The Alternate Wonder Woman: Jaimie Alexander
Jaime Alexander’s Role in the MCU
Jaimie Alexander, known for her determined portrayal of Lady Sif in the Thor films, was once in consideration for the role of Wonder Woman. While Sif may not have been a primary character like Thor or Loki, her fierce demeanor and warrior spirit resonated with fans and comic readers alike. In a 2016 interview with Variety, Alexander revealed that she had indeed been part of early discussions for the Wonder Woman role:
“I was one of a few people that were an obvious choice for Wonder Woman, but it was never going to happen. I’m contracted with Marvel and it would [be] strange.”
While she didn’t delve deep into the specifics, her statement suggests she was genuinely considered alongside other actresses who could embody Diana Prince. Given her impressive superhero credentials and dynamic screen presence, it’s clear why Warner Bros. found her a compelling candidate. However, cross-franchise casting posed significant obstacles, with competing companies fiercely guarding their intellectual properties.
Lady Sif as Marvel’s Take on Wonder Woman
Similarities between Sif and Wonder Woman
Interestingly, Lady Sif shares numerous traits with Wonder Woman. Both characters are formidable warriors committed to justice and honor, adorned in battle-appropriate armor and wielding weapons. In the same interview, Alexander pointed out the overlapping qualities:
“Sif, in her way, is Marvel’s Wonder Woman. They’re both ethereal and have armor and a sword, and have special abilities; the physicality of the role is very similar.”
Unlike many female superheroes of early MCU, Sif stood as an equal alongside her male counterparts, reminiscent of Wonder Woman’s strength and independence. Even without transitioning to the DCEU, Alexander effectively portrayed a powerful warrior role that resonates with audiences.
What Could Have Been: Jaimie Alexander as Wonder Woman
The Potential of Alexander as Wonder Woman
Imagining Jaimie Alexander as Wonder Woman captivates many fans, as her portrayal of Sif exemplifies attributes expected of Diana Prince. In Thor: The Dark World, for instance, Alexander showcased a combat style and confidence that could easily translate to the role of an Amazonian warrior. Her commanding screen presence, even in brief moments such as her encounters with Loki, illustrates her ability to convey strength blended with femininity.
While contractual obligations prevented a crossover from happening, the fascination surrounding Alexander’s possible casting continues to thrive, especially considering her portrayal of Sif; she possesses the essential traits that could have made her a compelling Diana Prince.
The Future of Wonder Woman in James Gunn’s DCU
Casting Decisions in the New DCU
As James Gunn and Peter Safran lead the reboot of the DC Universe, the casting of Wonder Woman remains an open question. There is potential for Jaimie Alexander to step into the role, although this prospect seems remote currently.
Despite surviving her last appearance in Thor: Love and Thunder, Sif’s future within the MCU appears uncertain, with no future projects prominently featuring her character. Should Marvel choose to retire Sif, it could pave the way for Alexander to be considered for Wonder Woman, although it’s notable that actors rarely transition between competing franchises for major roles.
At present, there has been no official announcement regarding the casting of Wonder Woman within Gunn’s new universe. The character will indeed be a part of the emerging continuity, but the specifics about her introduction—whether in her own movie or integrated into a larger narrative—remain unconfirmed. Given her well-established presence and skill set, Alexander could emerge as a compelling candidate if direction shifts towards a fresh portrayal of Wonder Woman that distinguishes itself from Gadot’s interpretation.
Source: Variety