The latest reveal from Season 23 of American Idol generated significant buzz online, particularly following the eliminations that occurred on April 20 and April 21. Viewers took to social media platforms to voice their frustrations and share their confusion regarding the outcomes, which included heated discussions about both the public voting system and the decisions made by the judges. Many fans expressed their discontent over the perceived changes in musical direction and questioned the criteria used during the selection process.
Key concerns raised by the audience revolved around allegations of favoritism, a bias towards certain genres, and the focus on storytelling elements overshadowing actual vocal prowess. As viewers reacted on social media, their comments showcased a wide range of sentiments about the recently concluded episode and the contestants that were eliminated.
Following the announcement of the results, audience reactions surged across various social media channels. Several fans shared their discontent regarding the show’s evolving format and direction.
“I guess they had to pick at least one weak link đ€· #americanidol”a tweet read.
“I stopped watching @AmericanIdol years ago because it stopped being about real talent and became all about flashiness and sad stories. This season I decided to give it another shot. Nothing has changed. @ABCNetwork, either fix it, or cancel the show. This is awful. #AmericanIdol”a person commented.
Some fans of American Idol were particularly concerned about the judges’ decisions regarding who to save from elimination. Many suggested a troubling trend of favoritism or inconsistency emerging in their choices.
“Honestly I’m disgusted with the results for American Idol. Did only MAGAts vote? What the F*CK are those results⊠#Idol #AmericanIdol”a user wrote.
“#AmericanIdol these judges s*ck. Their blatant bias for these “underdogs” Josh, Amanda and Madi is what caused the real ones to go home too early. Now I remember why I stopped watching this show years ago. Done watching.”a user commented.
“So tired of all the screaming singing, don’t think it does anything for their voices. But I guess it is the music these days. #americanidol”a tweet read.
Despite the strong negative feedback, there were also many positive comments regarding recent episodes. A segment of viewers expressed enthusiasm about the notable increase in gospel and faith-themed performances, highlighted during the recent “Songs of Faith”episode.
“Lord the way these Black singers on #AmericanIdol this season has turned it into a Gospel Fest that I’m LOVING đ They preaching while singing country songs & trying not to run off stage đ„”a user wrote.
“Wow I haven’t watched #AmericanIdol for years! If I had known they were going to perform praise music I would have tuned in live! And Carrie Underwood’s performance was breathtaking!!!”a commentator shared.
“This is THE MOST Black people I have EVER seen make it into #AmericanIdol top 14, EVER.”a tweet read.
Top 14 Results for American Idol Season 23
On April 20, American Idol featured a “Songs of Faith”theme, with contestants performing spiritual tunes to celebrate Easter Sunday. The performances were open to public voting, and the results directly influenced which competitors would progress in the competition.
By the close of the April 20 episode, four contestantsâKyana Fanene, Grayson Torrence, MKY, and Penny Samarâwere voted off, leaving the competition solely based on viewer input. The remaining 20 contestants returned on April 21 to find out their fates.
After public voting, the first nine contestants for the Top 14 were decided, while six othersâBaylee Littrell, Zaylie Windsor, Drew Ryn, Isaiah Misailegalu, Olivier Bergeron, and Victor Solomonâwere eliminated due to low vote counts.
Following this reduction, the five contestants remaining in the so-called “danger zone”awaited the judges’ decisions. Judges Luke Bryan, Lionel Richie, and guest judge Carrie Underwood had the crucial task of choosing which contestants to save. Ultimately, Desmond Roberts, Josh King, ChĂ©, Amanda Barise, and Madi were selected to continue in the competition.
Stay tuned to American Idol on ABC or catch up anytime on Hulu.