On March 5, 2025, Pitchfork, a renowned American online music magazine, stirred controversy by rating BLACKPINK’s Lisa’s debut album, Alter Ego, a mere 5.2 out of 10. This unexpected critique left many fans in disbelief, as the publication delivered a harsh verdict on her work. The review highlighted perceived shortcomings in the album, asserting that Lisa struggled to showcase her artistic depth outside of her K-pop girl group.
“Lisa who is part of K-pop girl group BLACKPINK, needs to convince you that she has depth without her bandmates. Alter Ego proves she doesn’t.”
Following the release of Pitchfork’s rating, discussions erupted across social media platforms. Many users expressed their disagreement with the review, asserting that it lacked fairness and constructive criticism.
“pitchfork literally hates on everyone.”
Fans voiced their concerns regarding the apparent bias within the review. Numerous comments suggested that the tone of the article came off as demeaning rather than analytical, leading to accusations of animosity towards the artist.
“I’ve read the article and it seems like it’s written by a whiny 15-year-old who’s describing their enemy in their diary. This isn’t a review; all the words you’ve used are condescending and obviously full of hatred and animosity. What did Lisa ever do to you to receive such hate,”- a fan reacted.
“Is it just fun to hate on this girl? like I genuinely wanna know? cus her music not bad AT ALL so what is it?!”- another fan shared.
“She isn’t trying anything, she just gave us an album with music that she likes. It’s a fun album with good hard beats. Not all songs have to have deep meaning to be good. You people forget that music is also about fun; that is where you miss,”- a fan commented.
Despite the negative review, many internet users steadfastly defended Lisa’s artistry, asserting their unwavering support for the BLACKPINK member.
“Pitchfork don’t know what real music is like, and it shows,”- a user reacted.
“5.2? Funny cause we don’t care about y’all rating,”- another user shared.
“Pitchfork being tasteless as always, nothing new here,”- a user commented.
BLACKPINK’s Lisa Unveils Alter Ego
Lisa’s solo debut, Alter Ego, was officially released on February 28, 2025, under the LLOUD label, with distribution by Sony Music for domestic markets and RCA Records for international audiences. The album consists of fifteen tracks, captivating listeners with a diverse range of styles and themes:
- Born Again (feat. Doja Cat & Raye)
- Rockstar
- Elastigirl
- Thunder
- New Woman (feat. Rosalia)
- Fxck Up The World (FUTW) (feat. Future)
- Rapunzel (feat. Megan Thee Stallion)
- Moonlit Floor (Kiss Me)
- When I’m With You (feat. Tyla)
- Badgrrrl
- Lifestyle
- Chill
- Dream
- Fxck Up The World (FUTW) Vixi Solo Version
- Rapunzel (Kiki Solo Version)
In a display of talent, Lisa also performed alongside British singer Raye and American rapper Doja Cat during the 2025 Oscars on March 2, further solidifying her impact in the music industry.