Craig Conover and Natalie Buffett: A New Chapter
In March 2025, Craig Conover, a prominent star from Southern Charm, made a significant announcement during his appearance on Watch What Happens Live with Andy Cohen. The reality TV personality revealed that he was “very happy” and currently dating someone special, although he initially kept his partner’s identity under wraps. However, just a month later, sources hinted to Us Weekly that the woman in question is none other than model and influencer Natalie Buffett.
“They are taking things slow and it’s still pretty new, but Craig is all in,” a source disclosed.
About Natalie Buffett: The Influencer Life
Natalie Buffett, at 27, brings her own flair to the relationship. Known for her work as a model and social media influencer, she has a history of dating well-known athletes, including NFL’s Dak Prescott and MLB’s Jack Flaherty. Originally hailing from Texas, Natalie divides her time between New York and Florida, often jet-setting for work commitments.
A Reconnection After Time Apart
The relationship between Craig and Natalie isn’t entirely new; it traces back to a brief encounter in 2019. According to insiders, their initial fling was marred by poor timing, although they stayed amicable. Fast forward to February 2025, when the two rekindled their connection through mutual friends. They have since been spotted sharing moments in both Charleston and New York City, marking the start of what appears to be a blossoming romance.
“Craig and Natalie met years ago and had a fling. It ended quickly and wasn’t good timing,” a source revealed.
Craig Conover on Timing and Destiny
During his March interview, Craig expressed a reflective sentiment regarding their reunion, noting the whims of the universe. He stated:
“I’ve been reminded that the universe works in crazy ways, and everything happens for a reason,” he shared.
Past Relationships and Moving Forward
Before his romance with Natalie, Craig was in a significant relationship with Paige DeSorbo, another reality TV star from Summer House. Their three-year relationship began in 2021 on the set of Winter House. However, as revealed in an April 2025 episode of Summer House, Paige addressed the difficulties they faced, citing feelings of being gaslit and unsupported amid long-distance challenges.
“I feel like I’m being gaslit into things that I need to compromise on,” Paige said, reflecting on her relationship with Craig before their late 2024 breakup.
While Paige has expressed her love for Craig, she acknowledged her internal conflicts regarding their future together. As rumors about Craig and Natalie gained traction, they were spotted celebrating New Year’s Eve in close proximity, with Craig in Aspen and Natalie in Vail.
Catch Up on Southern Charm
Fans can keep up with the latest developments in Craig’s life and more dramatic moments from Southern Charm, which is currently streaming on Bravo.