Married At First Sight is facing significant challenges in its 18th season, with many couples expressing dissatisfaction over the limited expert guidance provided. Participants have voiced concerns that the current panel of relationship experts may need a reevaluation. While the show has featured long-standing experts like Dr. Pepper Schwartz and Pastor Cal Roberson, the inclusion of Dr. Pia Holec has not compensated for the apparent lack of support during critical moments in the couples’ journeys.
This season, partners have struggled to establish meaningful connections as they navigate the early phases of their marriages. Although the participants entered the program with hope that the marriage format would lead to lasting bonds, the experts have been notably absent, leaving some couples like Camille and Thomas managing well independently, while others, including Michelle and David, require more substantial assistance.
Experts Are Less Present Than Ever
Underwhelming Expert Engagement
Throughout Married At First Sight season 18, the participation of the experts has been minimal. Traditionally, these professionals play a crucial role in guiding couples through their relationships. However, aside from a brief appearance during the matchmaking special, their presence has dwindled significantly. Without adequate guidance, couples are finding it challenging to identify and articulate their issues, leaving them to face obstacles without expert intervention.
This lack of timely advice has bewildered viewers, especially since foundational moments in relationships typically require more expert support than ever. The slow rollout of guidance contrasts sharply with expectations from previous seasons, where experts were more proactively involved.
Consistently Low Success Rates
Few Successful Matches

In recent seasons, there has been a growing sentiment among viewers that the expert panel has struggled to facilitate lasting unions. Just two matches have successfully transitioned beyond the final Decision Day in the past six seasons. Despite their best efforts, this low success rate has not only raised eyebrows but also fostered a perception among the audience that the experts may not be wholly accountable for the outcomes of these relationships.
Urgent Need for Expert Panel Overhaul in Season 19
Immediate Changes Required
As seasoned experts continue to participate in the show, the question arises: what changes are necessary to improve the experience for participants? With Married At First Sight season 18 showing signs of potential failure for many of the couples, it is imperative for the show to reconsider its expert panel ahead of the next season. Ongoing challenges may further undermine audience trust in the concept if improvements are not made swiftly.
As a reminder, Married At First Sight airs Tuesdays at 8 p.m. EST on Lifetime.
Source: Married At First Sight/Instagram