With the recent release of American Primeval in January 2025, viewers seeking another Western experience rife with intensity can turn to Taylor Sheridan’s acclaimed Yellowstone universe. This Netflix series transports audiences to 1857—a pivotal year marked by the conflict between the Mormon church and the original settlers of Utah—and tells the gripping tale of a mother and son eager to escape their perilous circumstances. Upon its release, American Primeval received commendations for its stark portrayal of violence and profound storytelling.
The release of American Primeval comes at a significant moment in the Western genre’s resurgence. Westerns have long been a fan favorite; however, over the past six years, Taylor Sheridan has emerged as a leading creative force, dominating the landscape with his compelling neo-Western narratives. Since the debut of Yellowstone in 2019, Sheridan has continued to produce well-loved series within this genre. Consequently, American Primeval appears to be Netflix’s strategic answer to Sheridan’s flourishing empire on Paramount+. As time has passed, one of the most fitting alternatives to American Primeval is actually a spinoff from Sheridan’s own Yellowstone series.
1883: The Closest Related Series to American Primeval
Exploring Similarities and Differences Between 1883 and American Primeval
Among the offerings in Sheridan’s Yellowstone universe, the series 1883, released in 2021, stands out as an apt follow-up to American Primeval. This one-season spinoff delves into the lives of the Dutton family’s ancestors striving to escape poverty in Texas as they embark on a treacherous journey towards a promising future in Montana—a place where they ultimately lay the foundation for the iconic Dutton ranch. The family is met with formidable challenges, forcing them to unite to survive in an unforgiving landscape. This series stars notable actors, including Tim McGraw, Faith Hill, Isabel May, Sam Elliott, and Billy Bob Thornton.
Both American Primeval and 1883 share thematic connections, prominently focusing on the same tumultuous era in American history. They follow the journeys of desperate individuals traversing the Great Plains, albeit in distinct narrative worlds. Despite their different settings, both series grapple with the same overarching struggles, rooted in the cultural conflicts of the period. The primary distinction lies in their narrative details: 1883 is deeply invested in character backstories, while American Primeval emphasizes its historical context alongside its diverse ensemble cast.
The Unique Brutality of American Primeval
Understanding the Lower Violence Level in the Yellowstone Universe
A key divergence between American Primeval and 1883 is the latter’s comparatively restrained depiction of violence. While 1883 does contain its share of intense moments, they pale in relation to the raw and graphic scenes presented in American Primeval. While most Westerns incorporate an element of gore reflective of their historical backdrop, American Primeval’s intensity sets it apart, making it a unique challenge for audiences seeking similar follow-up content.
When 1883 was conceived, it followed the established narrative tone set by Yellowstone, which generally refrains from excessive graphic violence. The modern-day setting of Yellowstone offers a different narrative lens, where overt brutality may appear out of place. Additionally, considerations regarding content restrictions on network television necessitated a less violent presentation in 1883, ensuring consistency with Yellowstone’s established brand.
The Potential Future of American Primeval in a Yellowstone-like Franchise
Recommended Viewing for Fans of American Primeval
A noteworthy potential for American Primeval is its capacity to evolve into a franchise akin to Yellowstone, spawning multiple seasons and spin-offs. At present, Netflix has yet to confirm a second season for American Primeval, which raises concerns among its fan base. Nonetheless, there remains optimism that the series could see a renewal, and if it continues to garner success, additional seasons may become a reality.
In the meantime, viewers eager for more Western narratives can explore options beyond American Primeval. While 1883 is a fantastic choice, for those seeking more excitement and violence, films like Bone Tomahawk may fit the bill. This gripping Western revolves around a sheriff assembling a group of men to rescue a kidnapped couple from a sinister cannibalistic tribe. These recommended titles should keep audiences engaged while they await further news regarding the future of American Primeval.