WARNING: Contains Potential Spoilers for BATMAN AND ROBIN #20!
The longstanding debate surrounding the efficacy of Batman‘s role in Gotham City continues to gain traction among critics and fans alike. Many argue that rather than improving the city, Batman’s presence has worsened the condition of Gotham. Now, in a bold move, DC Comics has echoed this sentiment with a definitive statement: “Gotham without Batman and Robin was better.”
In a twist of irony, both Robin and his detractors converge on the conclusion that Batman’s attempts to save Gotham have led to its deterioration.
Insights from Batman and Robin #20
In the latest issue, Batman and Robin #20—crafted by writer Phillip Kennedy Johnson and artists Miguel Mendonça and Juni Ba—the narrative takes a gripping route following Robin’s abduction. As Bruce Wayne, affected by hallucinations caused by the villain Memento, rummages through his son’s room for clues, he stumbles upon a comic authored by Damian. Titled “The Adventures of Batman and Robin,”this comic offers profound insights into Damian’s mind and perception of their roles as heroes.
Damian Wayne’s Revelations
Within his comic, Damian articulates complex thoughts about both his and his father’s roles as Batman and Robin, influenced significantly by revelations from Thomas Wayne’s journals. One pivotal realization stands out: heroism is not restricted to caped figures; everyday people—such as doctors—can also embody heroism. This epiphany is coupled with a stark conclusion: “Gotham without Batman and Robin was better.”
The accompanying artwork starkly portrays a cycle of violence, emphasizing that Damian perceives their ‘heroism’ as ultimately detrimental to Gotham. This narrative angle resonates powerfully with criticisms leveled against Batman, suggesting that his vigilantism perpetuates violence rather than alleviating it.
Analyzing the “Batman Makes Gotham Worse”Critique
Critics have long contended that Batman’s presence escalates the chaos within Gotham. This idea resonates deeply, echoing sentiments expressed in Christopher Nolan’s iconic Dark Knight trilogy. For instance, Commissioner Gordon asserts, “We start carrying semi-automatics, they buy automatics.” This illustrates the cyclical nature of violence—the more Batman fights crime, the more criminals escalate their efforts to counter him. Interestingly, the emergence of Gotham’s most notorious villains, such as the Joker, correlates with Batman’s appearance, further supporting the argument that his vigilantism contributes to the city’s instability.
Ultimately, BATMAN AND ROBIN #20 serves as a bold chapter in this ongoing narrative, revealing internal conflicts and perspectives that challenge the traditional hero archetype—asserting that perhaps Batman’s legacy is, contrary to popular belief, one that harms rather than heals Gotham.
BATMAN AND ROBIN #20 is currently available from DC Comics!