Concerns About FFXIV: Dawntrail’s Phantom Weapons Mimicking Troubling Relic Weapon Trends

Final Fantasy XIV: Dawntrail Unveils Its Relic Weapons

Patch 7.25 for Final Fantasy XIV: Dawntrail introduces a much-anticipated feature: Relic Weapons. These weapons have always been coveted, not only for their practical superiority as best-in-slot choices (surpassing even Savage items) but also for their aesthetic appeal in the game’s glamour system. However, players should brace themselves for a grueling return to the classic grind for gathering the components necessary to forge these Relic Weapons.

Reviving the Classic Grind

To acquire Phantom Weapons, players will venture into the new Occult Crescent field operation. This approach harkens back to the original farming mechanics used for Relic Weapons from A Realm Reborn through Shadowbringers, characterized by a mix of random number generation (RNG) and potential frustration. While the addition of Phantom Weapons is certainly appealing, the method for obtaining them may not elicit the same excitement.

Challenges of Collecting Phantom Relics

Veterans of the game will recognize the familiar structure of collecting Phantom Relics. Players will be tasked with gathering one or more specific items that must be exchanged with an NPC, requiring multiple iterations to gather the sufficient quantity. The grinding doesn’t stop there; further efforts are required to upgrade these weapons to their pinnacle form, ultimately leading to a tedious and often frustrating experience for players.

For players invested in multiple classes, the endeavor to obtain a single Relic Weapon could stretch over weeks, as those participating in multiple job roles face an even longer slog. By incorporating significant RNG elements and demanding substantial collections for drop items, the game ensures players remain engaged—albeit sometimes unenthusiastically—as they await the next expansion.

Understanding the Grind and RNG Dilemma

The design philosophy behind the Phantom Relics appears aimed at sustaining the player base between expansions. With FFXIV currently experiencing fluctuations in player numbers, particularly post-Endwalker and amid mixed reviews during Dawntrail, the reliance on grind mechanics becomes clearer. Historically, player engagement tends to dip during the patch cycle following an expansion, with subsequent rebounds once new content arrives.

The necessity to adapt the grind and RNG mechanics can be crucial for the longevity of the Relic Weapons. While the initial thrill of pursuing these weapons is undeniable, the novelty can quickly diminish when faced with a repetitive loop aimed at securing necessary drops. A potential remedy might be to enhance the drop rates, thereby creating a less arduous experience overall.

Seeking Improved Methods for Relic Acquisition

The approach to Relic Weapons taken during Endwalker was distinguishable, incorporating Hildebrand quests and implementing tomestone grinding rather than RNG-based item drops. This design led to criticism that the Relic Weapons were too accessible, prompting a return to a grind-centric model with Phantom Weapons. Without clear timelines on how long it may take to secure a singular Phantom Relic, it appears neither strategy provides a flawless experience.

The current state of gameplay suggests a necessity for innovations in how future content, including Relic Weapons, is structured. As the community discusses the ongoing evolution of FFXIV, dissatisfaction related to outdated farming methods and RNG-based mechanics continues to surface. It is increasingly evident that the game must contemplate its approach to crafting engaging content for the next decade.

Source & Images

© 2021 The Filibuster Blog