Warning: This article contains spoilers for Sunrise on the Reaping by Suzanne Collins.
Suzanne Collins has delved back into the dystopian world of The Hunger Games, giving fans two prequels: The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes and the upcoming Sunrise on the Reaping. As the 2025 release date approaches, fans are left pondering which of the two narratives—focusing on Haymitch Abernathy and Coriolanus Snow—stands superior. Collins’ original trilogy has redefined young adult dystopian fiction, making any addition to this beloved universe a cause for excitement. Yet, Sunrise on the Reaping distinguishes itself from its predecessor, primarily centering on the character of Haymitch instead of the notorious Snow.
Although it occurs 24 years prior to the events of The Hunger Games, Sunrise on the Reaping reinvigorates the franchise after the dark exploration of President Snow’s origins. Each prequel has unique merits, offering various insights into Panem’s societal issues, but one clearly outshines the other in terms of storytelling.
Haymitch Abernathy vs. Coriolanus Snow: A Clash of Protagonists
Haymitch: The More Relatable and Engaging Protagonist
For avid fans of The Hunger Games, the preference for Haymitch Abernathy as a protagonist is clear. While Coriolanus Snow offers a haunting and intricate perspective, his character can be difficult to empathize with. Collins’ portrayal is intentional, forcing readers to contemplate the complexities of his ambition and moral failure.
In contrast, Sunrise on the Reaping presents a much more sympathetic view of Haymitch at a younger age, highlighting his depth and relatable struggles.
Interestingly, while young Coriolanus hints at the tyrant he becomes, Haymitch’s character evolution feels like rediscovering an old friend. The stark difference between young Haymitch and the bitter mentor seen in Katniss’ journey adds layers to his story, making the emotional weight of his backstory resonate more profoundly.
Love Interests: Lucy Gray vs. Lenore Dove
Lucy Gray: A Compelling Love Interest with Broader Significance
Both prequels feature love interests from the Covey; however, Lenore Dove in Sunrise on the Reaping falls short when compared to the vibrant Lucy Gray Baird from The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes. Lucy plays a significant and dynamic role not just in her story but across the franchise, leaving a lasting impression that Lenore struggles to match.
Lucy Gray provides a much-needed anchor in a narrative that can often be dark and challenging, making her a figure readers are eager to root for during the tumult of the 10th Hunger Games. Her charisma as a performer and her colorful persona stand out, enhancing her significance in the franchise.
Comparing the Supporting Casts of Both Prequels
Supporting Characters in Sunrise on the Reaping Are More Memorable
While The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes introduces some engaging side characters like Tigris and Sejanus, they are often overshadowed by Snow’s narrative. The tributes, specifically in the context of Lucy Gray’s competition, lack the detailed exploration that draws readers in, resulting in less memorable impressions.
Conversely, the diverse and richly developed characters in Sunrise on the Reaping—both familiar faces from the original series and new personalities—enhance the overall story. Notable characters like Mags, Beetee, and Wiress get significant backstories, providing innovative layers that deepen the reader’s connection to the Hunger Games universe.
How the Narratives of Sunrise on the Reaping and The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes Stack Up
An Enjoyable Dive into Haymitch’s Backstory
When evaluating narrative structure and themes, both The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes and Sunrise on the Reaping are commendable. However, the latter offers a more enjoyable reading experience. This can largely be attributed to its engaging protagonist and a stronger cast of characters, which provide deeper connections to Katniss’ journey.
Expanding the Hunger Games Universe: Which Prequel Excels?
The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes: A More Intriguing Setting
While Sunrise on the Reaping may have a compelling story, The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes enriches the universe of The Hunger Games by providing a deeper look into Panem’s societal structure during its earlier years. The contrasts in the arena designs and the evolving nature of the Hunger Games enhance the world-building felt in Collins’ work.
Which Prequel Connects More Effectively to the Original Trilogy?
Haymitch’s Story: A Seamless Transition into Katniss Everdeen’s Saga
In establishing connections to The Hunger Games trilogy, Sunrise on the Reaping functions as an effective bridge to Katniss Everdeen’s narrative. It engrossingly prepares readers for the complexities of the uprising, examining pivotal moments that shape Katniss’ motivations and character interactions in Catching Fire and beyond.
Sunrise on the Reaping: The Superior Hunger Games Prequel
Haymitch’s Story Rivals the Original Series
Although Lucy Gray is a standout character in The Ballad of Songbirds and Snakes, Sunrise on the Reaping ultimately prevails as the more impactful prequel, offering a richer emotional depth and a faster-paced, engaging reading experience. It acts as a compelling reminder of the qualities that made the original trilogy so beloved, establishing Haymitch’s journey almost on par with the original novels, while the narrative in Ballad feels somewhat detached despite its merits.