WARNING! Spoilers ahead for Chicago Fire Season 13, Episode 17, “A Beast Like This,”and Chicago Med Season 10, Episode 16, “Book of Archer.”
Exploring Emotional Turmoil in One Chicago Franchise
In the gripping episodes of the One Chicago franchise, particularly in Chicago Fire Season 13, Episode 17, titled “A Beast Like This,”we witness a distinct yet profound emotional disconnect that sheds light on a character’s struggle with grief. This follows a pivotal moment in Chicago Med Season 10, Episode 16, “Book of Archer,”where Dr. Dean Archer (played by Steven Weber) grapples with the tragic news of his ex-wife’s passing in an accident after years apart.
Two Characters, Two Griefs: A Comparative Analysis
Archer’s emotional journey in “Book of Archer”serves as a backdrop for examining his explosive reactions to personal trauma. The episode provides viewers with a raw portrayal of Archer attempting to navigate his grief while managing the pressures of his medical duties. Conversely, in “A Beast Like This,”firefighter Dom Pascal faces a similar challenge but in a different context. After witnessing a severe accident involving a young girl, Pascal’s repressed emotions surface, leading to an aggressive outburst directed at the driver deemed responsible.
Archer’s Grief: A Reflection on the Past
The character dynamics reveal that Archer’s sorrow emanates not only from the immediate loss but from a lifetime of regrets and unresolved issues regarding his relationship with his late ex-wife. His interactions with Sean (Luigi Sottile), their shared past, and Archer’s feelings of missed opportunities emphasize an inner turmoil that is deeply rooted in nostalgia and what-ifs.
Pascal’s Grief: Fresh Wounds and Ongoing Struggles
In stark contrast, Pascal’s mourning is immediate and visceral. His recent loss of his wife, Monica, is still fresh and manifests in unfiltered emotions, particularly when juxtaposed with a tragic accident that resonates deeply with him. This prompts his vehement reaction at the accident scene, illustrating how unprocessed grief can influence a person’s behavior.
Setup and Execution: The Divergent Paths of Grief
While both characters face their grief, the execution differs significantly. Archer’s emotional breakdown appears sudden and disconnected, lacking sufficient build-up in the narrative. By treating it as a standalone event, the writers may have intended to encapsulate the shock of sudden loss. However, this method diminishes the overall impact, leaving viewers longing for a deeper exploration of Archer’s emotional state throughout the series, rather than a fleeting moment of reaction.
In contrast, Chicago Fire develops Pascal’s grief consistently, providing a more satisfying narrative arc that resonates with audiences. As he grapples with memories and the reality of loss, viewers gain insight into his ongoing struggle, fostering empathy and connection.
For those invested in the emotional depth of the One Chicago universe, it’s evident that the framing of each character’s grief impacts viewer engagement, demonstrating the importance of narrative continuity in portraying complex emotions effectively.
Interested in more insights from the One Chicago universe? Keep up with our weekly coverage for a closer look at your favorite shows. Read more here.