Why Polyfamily Is an Addictive Slow-Motion Drama (Surpassing Sister Wives)

I’ve recently become captivated by the new unscripted series Polyfamily. This fascinating show explores a closed polycule—a term used to denote a group of three or more individuals engaged in intimate polyamorous relationships. For context, I find it reminiscent of another TLC production, Sister Wives, as both series delve into unconventional family dynamics. Initially, I had reservations about watching this show, but it quickly drew me in, with its focus on two couples who embark on a journey of dating each other’s spouses, moving in together, and creating a unique family unit.

Understanding the Closed Polyamorous Dynamic

Meet the Couples

The premiere episode introduces us to Sean and Taya, alongside Tyler and Alicia, illustrating their intricate relationships. Both couples share a cumulative family life, including four children, with a fifth on the way. As I watched the initial episodes unfold, I felt an overwhelming sensation akin to witnessing a slow-motion car crash, unable to avert my gaze.

In the series opener, we are presented with an intimate confessional from the two couples. Sean states, “Taya’s my wife, and Alicia’s my girlfriend,”while Tyler responds, “Alicia’s my wife, and Taya’s my girlfriend.”These declarations succinctly encapsulate the premise of Polyfamily, which revolves around these two men effectively sharing their wives.

Alicia, 34, and Tyler, 36, have been together for over a decade, having met at 18 and 20, while Sean, 46, and Taya, 28, have celebrated six years of marriage. It’s crucial to note that this arrangement does not involve swinging; rather, they pursue a collective family identity. Alicia and Taya maintain separate bedrooms, and the men alternate between them, creating a structure that facilitates their unique living situation. Given that both men share intimate connections with both women, it raises the question of fatherhood—could either man be the biological father of their children?

Paternity Uncertainty in the Family

The Fatherhood Dilemma

Before merging into this polyamorous dynamic, Tyler and Alicia already had two children. Together with Sean and Taya, they welcomed two more children, with Taya currently pregnant with their fifth child. The striking aspect of their arrangement is the uncertainty around the paternity of their youngest offspring, as either man could be the father. While they claim it doesn’t matter, the issue clearly weighs on Tyler’s mind.

A recent episode revealed the significance of this uncertainty when Tyler accidentally shared their new baby’s blood type in a group chat. A simple search led Sean to uncover the truth: the baby couldn’t be biologically his. This shocking revelation has the potential to disrupt their already complex familial bonds.

Navigating Jealousy and Insecurity

Dealing with Insecurity

In addressing the complexities of jealousy and insecurity, the show’s cast openly discusses their feelings. Alicia confessed to experiencing anxiety about her relationship, particularly regarding Tyler’s closeness to Taya. This dynamic appears to foster underlying resentment that could dramatically surface throughout the series.

Taya seems to take pleasure in stoking these insecurities, insinuating during a confessional that her intimate relationship with Tyler is superior to Alicia’s. This revelation prompts Alicia’s emotional breakdown as she bemoans her discomfort with her husband’s relationships. It raises questions about the motivations for her participation in this polycule: Is Alicia truly invested in this lifestyle, or is she clinging to her husband out of fear?

Why Polyfamily Outshines Sister Wives

A Hotbed of Dramatic Tension

When Sister Wives debuted in 2010, the Brown family presented themselves as a largely happy polygamous unit. While they certainly faced challenges, the foundation of their relationships seemed stable. In stark contrast, Polyfamily introduces a higher level of dysfunction right from the start. It is evident that this series promises more dramatic twists than Sister Wives, especially as implications arise regarding the viability of Sean, Taya, Tyler, and Alicia’s relationships.

Polyfamily airs Tuesdays at 10 p.m. EDT on TLC. For those intrigued by unique relationship dynamics and swirling drama, it’s a show worth tuning into.

Source & Images