Overview of Pirate Strength
- Whitebeard’s Devil Fruit power may surpass Roger’s in destructive capacity.
- While Roger and Whitebeard were evenly matched, Whitebeard’s abilities could have tipped the scales in his favor.
- Rocks D. Xebec remains a legendary figure, arguably the strongest pirate in history, exceeding even Roger and Whitebeard.
In the lore of One Piece, few names are as iconic as Gol D. Roger and Edward ‘Whitebeard’ Newgate. Roger, the sole individual to bear the title of Pirate King, was celebrated for his extraordinary strength, while Whitebeard was famed not only for his might but also for his capability to potentially obliterate entire landscapes.
The rivalry between these two legendary figures has defined a significant era in One Piece, showcasing their balanced power in numerous encounters. A particularly notable clash occurs during Oden’s flashback in the Wano arc, where they engaged in a three-day-long battle that ultimately ended in a stalemate. Yet a substantial faction of the fan base leans towards the belief that Whitebeard could have been the stronger of the two, prompting an exploration of this perspective.
Whitebeard’s Potential Superiority Over Roger
Analyzing the Rivalry
In discussions regarding the pinnacle of pirate prowess, both Roger and Whitebeard dominate the conversation. Despite Roger achieving the coveted title of Pirate King, Whitebeard’s disinterest in such a title does not diminish his legacy. Their rivalry was as formidable as their strengths, often portrayed as equals who fought to a draw on multiple occasions.
However, there’s a compelling argument among fans suggesting that Whitebeard may have held back during their encounters. The only illustrated battle between them occurred during Oden’s flashback, leading many to view it as representative of their typical confrontations. Here, both pirates demonstrated enhanced mastery of Haki, but Whitebeard’s choice not to utilize his Devil Fruit powers during this encounter raises speculations about his true potential.
Although there’s no definitive answer due to the lack of showcased battles, fans frequently revisit this single confrontation as a benchmark for their rivalry. With their Haki skills evidently at par, the destructive abilities tied to Whitebeard’s Gura Gura no Mi may have afforded him a critical advantage had he chosen to amplify his capabilities.
Speculation arises around the notion that, if circumstances allowed for an all-out conflict without the bonds of friendship, Whitebeard’s unmatched destructive prowess could have led him to victory. Sengoku’s commentary during the Marineford War emphasized Whitebeard’s capacity for world-destroying strength, which implies that this unique power could have shifted the tides against Roger.
Even while battling ailments during the Marineford War, Whitebeard’s solo combat against overwhelming naval forces showcased his immense prowess as a one-man army. His reputation suggested that his full strength was never truly measured; the presence of his crew may have restrained his complete capability, which some fans argue renders Haki less relevant in the context of his Devil Fruit alone.
The Enigma of the Greatest Pirate
Rocks D. Xebec: The Unseen Titan
Historically, Roger and Whitebeard are celebrated as the strongest pirates of their generation. However, this accolade may overshadow the reality of Rocks D. Xebec, a figure whose legacy has been largely obscured. It is suggested that Rocks surpassed even Roger and Whitebeard in strength, forming a crew that included Whitebeard, and was powerful enough to compel Roger and Garp to join forces against him.
The lore surrounding Rocks continues to intrigue fans, and while Roger and Whitebeard’s might are well-documented, the extent of Rocks’ power looms large in the shadows of pirate history. The debate surrounding the strength of Roger versus Whitebeard will persist, but it is clear that Rocks D. Xebec potentially reigns as the ultimate pirate of their age.
One Piece is available for streaming on Crunchyroll.