Warning: Spoilers for Doctor Odyssey Season 1, Episode 18.
The future of Doctor Odyssey remains ambiguous, particularly after the season finale which suggests that a second season may be unnecessary. Starring Joshua Jackson as Dr. Max Bankman, the head of the medical wing on the show, the ABC procedural features a cast that includes Phillipa Soo as Nurse Practitioner Avery Morgan and Sean Teale as Nurse Tristan Silva. Together, they confront a range of medical emergencies intertwined with outlandish theme weeks. Intriguingly, much of the series’ most thrilling plots have less to do with medicine and more with the characters’ intricate relationships.
Viewers have been kept on edge throughout the season due to the romantic entanglements among Avery, Max, and Tristan, creating a cycle of pairings and breakups. Captain Robert Massey, portrayed by Don Johnson, faced dramatic personal stakes as he navigated potential fatherhood with Heather (for entertainer Shania Twain) while juggling job security. The season finale escalated to a cataclysmic showdown with an earthquake, tsunami, and aftershocks. Uncertainty looms over whether this concluding episode serves as a temporary cliffhanger or marks the end of the road for Doctor Odyssey.
Doctor Odyssey’s Renewal Relies on Ryan Murphy’s Strategy
The Future of the Series Hangs on Its Creator’s Decision
The ambiguity surrounding Doctor Odyssey ‘s renewal can leave fans perplexed, especially since the debut season has outperformed established hits like Grey’s Anatomy in viewership ratings—typically a strong indicator for renewal. However, the holdup stems from the vision of its creator, Ryan Murphy. Unlike usual protocols, the next steps for Doctor Odyssey hinge on whether Murphy can prioritize this show amidst his busy slate, which includes other commitments like 9-1-1 and Hulu’s All’s Fair.
Despite achieving solid viewer metrics in its inaugural season, the series risks becoming a passing phenomenon if Ryan Murphy opts not to pursue its continuation. While some industry observers express concerns about narrative sustainability given the confined setting and limited cast, potential revisions and guidance from a dedicated production team could address these issues effectively.
Season 1’s Finale Sets the Stage for a Potential Series Conclusion
Loose Plot Threads Have Been Resolved
If “The Wave”truly marks the end, the finale of Doctor Odyssey successfully wraps up character arcs with some semblance of happiness. Following a dramatic rescue mission after the tsunami, Captain Massey finds himself on the brink of dismissal but is ultimately saved by his crew in a show of unity. Each main character introduced earlier survives, culminating in a beach wedding officiated by Massey, offering a heartfelt conclusion.
Most notably, the show resolves its tangled love triangle narrative. Avery expresses her feelings for Max, committed to nurturing their relationship while continuing her education. Max, in turn, supports her ambitions, suggesting that distance won’t hinder their bond. Meanwhile, Tristan gets a moment of clarity, choosing to let Avery pursue her goals, thus concluding the season with personal growth and a clearer path forward.
Season 2 Could Diverge Significantly From Season 1
The Series Could Evolve with Significant Changes
Should a second season be greenlit, multiple narrative avenues await exploration in Doctor Odyssey. A time jump that bypasses Avery’s med school years could streamline the narrative, but a more dynamic approach might be splitting storylines between the land and sea environments. Tristan’s unresolved romantic arc with Vivian presents an opportunity for a return, now that he’s ready to move forward. Additionally, the crew aboard the Odyssey could receive deeper development, allowing for expanded character arcs.
There’s also room for tonal experimentation. Embracing its campiness could lead to a unique musical episode featuring the vocal talents of Phillipa Soo, known for her Broadway roots. Conversely, a deeper existential thread could be woven into the narrative, considering the “purgatory theory” highlighted in the finale. The necessity of a second season remains an open-ended question, but if Ryan Murphy decides to embrace the challenge, Doctor Odyssey could shine anew.
All episodes of Doctor Odyssey are now available for streaming on Hulu.
Interested in exclusive insights from the world of primetime television? Sign up below for our weekly Network TV newsletter, tailored for fans eager to delve into the latest updates and insider information from the series they love.
SIGN UP NOW!