Since its debut in 2014, the Below Deck franchise has evolved into a significant force in the realm of reality television, introducing viewers to various personalities and dramatic encounters aboard luxury yachts. Central to its enduring appeal are the cast members, some of whom have faced public backlash due to their questionable actions on-screen. However, there are certain individuals whose return could provide them with a chance at redemption, potentially reshaping viewer opinions.
The franchise has expanded significantly with multiple spin-offs, including Below Deck Mediterranean (2016), Below Deck Sailing Yacht (2020), and the latest additions like Below Deck Adventure and Below Deck Down Under, which is currently airing its third season. Throughout these iterations, several cast members have behaved in ways that led them to be deemed irredeemable. Yet, there are a select few who have the potential and desire to return, correct their past mistakes, and win back the audience’s approval.
For example, cast members such as Kyle Dickard from Below Deck Adventure and Luke Jones from Below Deck Down Under showcased alarmingly inappropriate behaviors that many believe negate any chance of redemption. However, six others stand out as candidates worthy of a second opportunity to demonstrate growth and maturity.
6 Heather Chase
Below Deck Season 9
Heather Chase joined as the Chief Stew in Below Deck Season 9, supervising Fraser Oldender and Jessica Albert. Tensions arose between her and Deckhand Rayna Lindsey after Heather used the “N-word”during a rap lyric rendition, which deeply offended Rayna. Although Heather apologized and attempted to learn from her mistakes, the incident left a mark on her reputation.
Despite her judgment lapse, Heather has shown remorse and a willingness to grow, having publicly addressed her actions via an Instagram apology. Her desire to learn from this experience signals her potential for redemption.
“I am sorry for the hurt my ignorance caused Rayna in tonight’s episode. While I apologized to Rayna throughout the season, I cannot express enough how truly remorseful I am. Part of my responsibility as Chief Stewardess is to provide a welcoming, safe environment for the crew…”
5 Jonathan Shillingford
Below Deck Med Season 9
Jonathan “Jono”Shillingford’s presence in Below Deck Mediterranean Season 9 ended prematurely when Captain Sandy Yawn dismissed him following a severe mishap where he inadvertently served a guest with a life-threatening seafood allergy. This significant error not only jeopardized a charter but also resulted in a fierce reprimand from Captain Sandy.
“I’m really f***ing pissed,”Captain Sandy openly expressed.
Despite his culinary talent and likability, Jono’s reputation took a hit due to this error. Nevertheless, with the right growth and concentration on detail, he has the potential for a comeback on the franchise, even if it may not be with Captain Sandy.
4 João Franco
Below Deck Med Seasons 3 & 4, Below Deck Down Under Season 2
João Franco made his mark in Below Deck Mediterranean Season 3 before returning as Bosun in Season 4. Initially pegged as a misogynist due to past behaviors, he attempted to shed his negative image in his subsequent appearances. Despite achieving some personal growth, his turbulent romantic developments and the resurfacing of his “Jezzaabob”alter ego muddied his progress.
However, recent portrayals in Below Deck Down Under show João striving for maturity. With his new title as captain, a return to the franchise could allow him to present a more positive persona.
3 Ryan McKeown
Below Deck Down Under Season 1
Ryan McKeown, who appeared in Below Deck Down Under Season 1, faced severe criticism due to his confrontational personality and denigrative remarks about Captain Jason upon his dismissal. While his actions were inappropriate, the potential for redemption exists.
With a clear talent in the kitchen, a return could allow Ryan to work towards regaining respect and showcasing his culinary skills, potentially captivating fans who crave an engaging redemption story.
2 Ashton Pienaar
Below Deck Seasons 6 & 7
Ashton Pienaar’s trajectory included being a Deckhand in Season 6 before his promotion to Bosun in Season 7. His near-death experience in Season 6 endeared him to audiences, but his behavior towards Kate Chastain during Season 7 tarnished his image, leading to his dismissal.
Since then, Ashton has publicly apologized and shifted his focus toward fitness coaching. With personal growth, there’s an opportunity for him to re-enter the franchise, redeem his past indiscretions, and possibly rebuild a positive persona.
1 Kyle Viljoen
Below Deck Med
Kyle Viljoen emerged as a fan favorite during his time as Second Stew in Below Deck Med Season 6, returning in Season 7. Known for his hard work and cheerful demeanor, Kyle’s interpersonal skills suffered. His tendency to gossip and instigate conflict created a toxic work environment—a sharp contrast to his otherwise upbeat attitude.
Following a stern talking-to from Captain Sandy, Kyle’s awareness of his behavior suggests he has the potential for redemption. Given his commitment and the right circumstances, a comeback could allow Kyle to demonstrate his dedication to his craft while also rectifying past wrongs.
The individuals highlighted here represent a mix of mistakes and potential. Each possesses qualities that could lead to a compelling storyline centered around redemption, making their return not just favorable for fan engagement but also impactful in demonstrating personal growth. With their respective journeys, viewers can anticipate an engaging narrative that offers valuable lessons about accountability and transformation.
Don’t miss new episodes of Below Deck Down Under, airing Mondays at 8 p.m. EDT on Bravo.