Throughout cinematic history, numerous classic sci-fi films have seen the fate of the remake, with varying degrees of success. While many adaptations struggle to surpass their original counterparts, some notable exceptions have emerged, showcasing creativity and fresh perspectives on beloved stories. The sci-fi genre, known for its grand ideas and inventive concepts, has often revived iconic tales, allowing filmmakers to explore innovative narratives. Consequently, Hollywood is quick to capitalize on franchises or stories that resonate with audiences, leading to remakes of even the most cherished sci-fi films.
Despite the common perception that remakes signal a lack of originality in Hollywood, they can indeed provide valuable reinterpretations. While some recent attempts have missed the mark—such as Tim Burton’s version of The Planet of the Apes or the lackluster 2012 remake of Total Recall—there have been successful adaptations that not only honor their source material but enhance the narrative. This article takes a closer look at ten sci-fi remakes that defy expectations and, in some cases, outshine their originals.
10
The Invisible Man (2020)
Remake Of The Invisible Man (1933)
H.G. Wells’ The Invisible Man has inspired various adaptations over the decades, most notably the 1933 film that became a staple in the Universal Monsters lineup. This original story follows a deranged scientist who discovers the secret of invisibility, leading to chaos and murder. While the classic film has its charm, the modern adaptation from 2020 offers a significantly darker twist.
This contemporary retelling focuses on Cecilia, played by Elisabeth Moss, who grapples with the psychological impact of her abusive ex-partner, a brilliant scientist turned malevolent figure. Instead of centering on the invisible man as the antagonist, the narrative shifts to Cecilia’s gradual descent into paranoia, making The Invisible Man a gripping psychological thriller that highlights the themes of control and survival.
9
Dredd (2012)
Remake Of Judge Dredd (1995)
The character of Judge Dredd, originating from the cult comic book series, was previously portrayed by Sylvester Stallone in a widely criticized 1995 adaptation. Stallone’s interpretation missed the mark by deviating from the character’s iconic presence, particularly by removing the character’s signature helmet, which alienated comic book fans.
Almost twenty years later, Karl Urban revitalized the role in Dredd, skillfully adhering to the character’s core traits while delivering an intense performance. The film embraced its R-rating, showcasing visceral action sequences that elevated the overall experience, despite a modest budget. Urban’s outstanding portrayal has left fans eager for a sequel, as the demand for Dredd 2 continues to grow.
8
The Fly (1986)
Remake Of The Fly (1958)
The 1958 film The Fly is remembered for its intriguing plot involving a scientist whose experiment goes horribly wrong, resulting in a grotesque transformation into a human-fly hybrid. While remarkable for its era, its execution may not resonate with today’s audiences seeking deeper narratives.
In sharp contrast, David Cronenberg’s 1986 remake is celebrated for its chilling body horror and complex storytelling. Jeff Goldblum’s descent into monstrosity coupled with Geena Davis’ compelling performance as his lover enriches the narrative, offering a tragic love story that explores themes of loss and transformation while delivering some of the most impressive practical effects in cinematic history.
7
The Blob (1988)
Remake Of The Blob (1958)
The original 1958 version of The Blob, featuring a young Steve McQueen, is a nostalgic favorite that revolves around a gelatinous alien entity ravaging a small town. While it successfully captured the campy spirit of the era, audiences were taken by surprise with the 1988 remake’s darker and more graphic approach to the narrative.
This updated version maintains the core plot but boldly kills off perceived heroes early in the film. The blend of shocking twists and impressive practical effects elevates The Blob remake, cementing its status as an overlooked classic within the sci-fi horror genre.
6
I Am Legend (2007)
Remake Of The Last Man On Earth (1964) & The Omega Man (1971)
Richard Matheson’s 1954 novel, I Am Legend, has spawned several adaptations over the years. The first notable versions were The Last Man on Earth featuring Vincent Price and The Omega Man with Charlton Heston, where both approached the tale of humanity’s struggle against vampiric creatures from different angles.
The 2007 remake, starring Will Smith, emerges as the most successful rendition, capturing the essence of isolation and survival while presenting striking visuals of a desolate New York City. Smith’s powerful performance, paired with an alternate ending that aligns closely with the original source material, has set the stage for an anticipated sequel, I Am Legend 2.
5
Dune (2021)
Remake Of Dune (1984)
Denis Villeneuve’s Dune (2021) is often considered more of an adaptation rather than a direct remake of David Lynch’s 1984 film. However, comparisons between the two are inevitable. Both aim to faithfully represent Frank Herbert’s complex narrative of Paul Atreides in the richly detailed universe of Arrakis.
Lynch’s earlier attempt, though ambitious, suffered from numerous issues due to studio interference, resulting in mixed reviews. Villeneuve’s interpretation, however, showcases an impressive cast, remarkable action sequences, and masterful world-building, demonstrating that Herbert’s intricate saga can indeed be adapted for the screen successfully, paving the way for future installments.
4
Godzilla Minus One (2023)
Remake Of Godzilla (1954)
The original Godzilla film, released in 1954, remains a landmark in monster cinema. While the special effects may seem dated, the film’s underlying themes of destruction and societal renewal after World War II continue to resonate. The film is not merely about monster action; it also features well-developed human characters, providing a deeper narrative.
In Godzilla Minus One, the story is reframed in a post-war context, exploring Godzilla’s emergence during Japan’s recovery following its wartime defeat. This reimagining delivers stunning special effects on a modest budget and focuses on compelling human stories, offering audiences a narrative that extends beyond monster mayhem.
3
12 Monkeys (1996)
Remake Of La Jetée (1962)
Acclaimed as one of the standout sci-fi films from the 1990s, 12 Monkeys is often surprising to fans when they learn it is a remake of the 1962 short film La Jetée. The original’s storyline of time travel and dystopia is effectively utilized in Terry Gilliam’s adaptation, where the protagonist attempts to avert a catastrophic future
Gilliam expands upon the themes of the original, leading to a complex and mind-bending narrative journey that culminates in a stunning twist. The film also features memorable performances, particularly by Brad Pitt, who delivers an Oscar-nominated portrayal that adds depth and nuance to this remarkable tale.
2
Invasion Of The Body Snatchers (1978)
Remake Of Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1956)
The 1956 adaptation of Invasion of the Body Snatchers is a remarkable sci-fi thriller that cleverly presents an alien takeover in a subtle yet terrifying manner. The film depicts alien spores that replicate humans, leading to a quiet but insidious invasion of a small town.
While the original is a classic in its own right, the 1978 remake enhances the narrative with a slow-building sense of dread that grips the audience. The film’s atmosphere captures the escalating tension, ultimately delivering one of the most shocking twist endings in cinema history.
1
The Thing (1982)
Remake Of The Thing From Another World (1951)
John Carpenter’s The Thing is not just a superior remake of the 1951 film The Thing from Another World; it is frequently celebrated as one of the greatest horror films ever made. Both adaptations are based on John W. Campbell Jr.’s novella Who Goes There?, depicting a group of Arctic researchers confronting a terrifying extraterrestrial lifeform.
Carpenter’s version significantly enhances the original by introducing the alien’s shape-shifting abilities, heightening the tension as characters grapple with paranoia and mistrust. The film is renowned for its masterful practical effects, creating chilling visuals that have left a lasting impact on the horror genre.