American Idol Season 23: Top 14 Contestants Revealed
The latest episode of American Idol Season 23, which aired on April 21, 2025, showcased the highly anticipated reveal of the Top 14 contestants. This episode followed a special “Songs of Faith”event that took place the night prior. Host Ryan Seacrest brought each contestant forward to announce whether they were safe or ranked in the bottom 10.
Contestant Performances: Celebratory and Redemption
The Top 10 finalists delivered uplifting performances, while those in the bottom 10 had another opportunity to impress the judges and potentially receive one of four coveted saves. Notably, Drew Ryn found herself in the bottom 10 after her rendition of “Million Reasons”by Lady Gaga. Although her vocal abilities garnered praise, judge Lionel Richie advised her to infuse more energy into her performances as the competition progresses.
Following the deliberations, Drew did not advance to the Top 14, a decision that left many fans disheartened. Among those moving forward were Desmond Roberts, Josh King, Che Chesterman, and Amanda Barise. The elimination of Drew, a beloved contestant throughout the season, sparked significant backlash among viewers.
Fan Reactions on Social Media
In the aftermath of the episode, fans expressed their astonishment and disappointment on X (formerly Twitter). Their reactions highlighted the emotional weight Drew’s elimination carried.
“I literally cant believe Drew didnt make it… I refuse to believe she wasnt in the top 14,”one fan commented.
“Drew Ryn #AmericanIdol I am in shock that you are not in the top 14. Especially having Josh there that makes no sense to me. I know you’re gonna have an amazing career,”another user said.
“I CANNOT BELIEVE DREW DIDN’T MAKE IT!!! What happened???? What pissed them off because you have to be insane not to have picked her!!! And all because she started on the floor?? What just happened????”an X user wrote.
“Josh over Drew is a F*CKING JOKE,”one tweet read.
Encouragement for Drew
Despite the disappointment, several fans encouraged Drew to stay positive and continue pursuing her passion for music.
“Don’t feel defeated. You had a great performance tonight. You have a good voice. Keep performing your time will come. Drew Ryn,”a fan wrote.
“Ugh I’m so annoyed. Josh!? Really!? Really wish Drew made it through,”one netizen tweeted.
“First Grayson Torrence did not make the cut from 24 to 20, and now Drew Ryn wasn’t voted into the Top 14? So disappointing,”a tweet said.
“Drew deserved a spot in the top 14,”another user commented.
Memorable Moments from the Results Show
The April 21 episode of American Idol was filled with standout performances as Seacrest unveiled the Top 14. Kolbi Jordan secured her spot with a soulful rendition of “Amazing Grace,”followed by a powerful performance of “I’m Every Woman.”Thunderstorm Artis also made his mark with “i love you”by Billie Eilish, celebrating his success.
Contestants in the bottom 10, including Drew, had a final chance to impress. While Drew sang “Million Reasons,”Olivier Bergeron attempted to sway the judges with “It’s Not My Time”by 3 Doors Down. Josh King, on the other hand, energized the audience with “Never Gonna Give You Up,”even incorporating an impressive harmonica solo that had the judges on their feet.
Ultimately, the judges selected Desmond Roberts, Josh King, Che Chesterman, and Amanda Barise to join the ranks of the Top 14. Gabby Samone also captured attention with her powerful performance of “Don’t Rain on My Parade,”which earned her a standing ovation from the audience.
Looking ahead, the Top 14 contestants are set to return for a Rock ‘n Roll Hall of Fame-themed episode, scheduled to air on April 27, 2025. Fans are eager to see how the competition unfolds in the coming weeks.